Puffy vs. Zenhaven Mattress Comparison 2023 : Which Is Better?

In This Article

View The Winner

We compared the Puffy memory foam mattress to the Zenhaven latex mattress to see which offers a more comfortable night sleep.

The comparison is close, both mattresses include the best qualities of their respective type, and each has a reputation for comfort and customer satisfaction.

About the Brands

The best way to describe the Puffy and Zenhaven mattresses is as opposites. Neither mattress is necessarily better than the other in one feature over another.

We would argue that a comparison of the Puffy and Zenhaven mattresses is more accurately a matter of preference for latex, or memory foam.

The Puffy mattress is soft where the Zenhaven mattress provides a firmer sleep surface, which makes preference the only determining factor.

The same can be said for varying degrees of support, contour and how much either mattress conforms to the shape of the body.

For these reasons, preference had to be removed as a determining factor in our comparison.

Puffy Recap Full Review

Puffy is one of the few mattress brands to enjoy a TV appearance and a celebrity endorsement. (Ellen DeGeneres) Puffy enjoys a positive reputation amongst customers who report being genuinely satisfied with their Puffy mattress.

The Puffy mattress is available in two different types, the Puffy, and the Puffy Lux. Each is constructed with multiple layers of memory foam and a support core.

When combined, these features create an exceptionally comfortable mattress that conforms to the body while remaining supportive of its most sensitive areas.

Why To Like

  • Motion Isolation
  • Conforms to the body
  • Reputation for customer satisfaction

Why To Doubt

  • Poor edge support
  • Expensive

ZenHaven Recap Full Review

Zenhaven does not have a celebrity endorsement. Instead, the brand relies on innovative design and all natural materials to provide a quality mattress that customers love.

Zenhaven is one of the few mattresses to feature a flippable design. Customers can choose between two different mattresses in one bed.

The Zenhaven mattress is manufactured from all natural Talalay latex which provides a firm sleep surface and phenomenal back pain relief.

Why To Like

  • Flippable design
  • Superior motion isolation
  • Great for back pain

Why To Doubt

  • Heavy
  • Expensive

Puffy and Zenhaven Mattress Comparison

How are Puffy and Zenhaven Mattresses Similar?

The Puffy and Zenhaven mattresses are very different in terms of mattress type, construction and the ways in which they provide a comfortable sleep surface.

However, a simple comparison reveals a significant number of similarities, especially concerning quality and overall customer satisfaction.

Customer Satisfaction – Customer feedback indicates that the majority of Puffy and Zenhaven mattress customers are satisfied with their mattress purchase.

The positive reviews are, in part due to the comfort of each mattress and reflect each brands’ commitment to customer service.

Motion Isolation – The Puffy and Zenhaven mattresses exhibit a high degree of motion isolation. Memory foam mattresses are soft and conforming. Thus they are expected to include high levels of motion isolation, and the Puffy mattress is no exception.

The Zenhaven mattress also includes high levels of motion isolation, which is surprising, as latex is typically far springier and more responsive than other mattress types.

Motion isolation is significant in the Zenhaven mattress because it features dual comfort layers of Talalay latex, which is softer and absorbs more motion than other latex types.

Product Selection – Zenhaven and Puffy customers can both select from two different mattresses, and firmness levels.

However, the Zenhaven mattress is flippable, enabling customers to enjoy the benefits of two mattresses in the same bed.

Conforming – The Puffy and Zenhaven mattresses conform to the body, albeit to varying degrees.

The Puffy mattress is constructed from soft polyfoam, which unsurprisingly makes it more conforming than the Zenhaven mattress.

However, because the Zenhaven mattress is constructed from soft Talalay latex it conforms to the body more than other latex mattress brands.

Great for Back Pain – Both mattresses provide a high level of back pain relief.

The soft polyfoam of the Puffy mattress contours to the spine, while its support core prevents the body from sinking too far into the mattress.

Thus, the Puffy mattress relieves stress on the spine and promotes a healthy spinal alignment.

The Zenhaven mattress is firmer than the Puffy mattress and more responsive, which enable it to remain supportive of the back and relieve troublesome pressure points.

Supportive Core – The Zenhaven and Puffy mattresses are both designed with a supportive core.

The Puffy mattress features a supportive core that prevents the body from sinking into the mattress, whereas the Zenhaven supportive core enables the flippable mattress to remain supportive on both sides.

Sleep Trial & Warranty – The Puffy and Zenhaven mattresses both include a warranty and an extended sleep trials over 100 days in which customers can return their purchase for a full refund, and even the cost of shipping.

Offgassing – Customers have reported some odor with the Puffy and Zenhaven mattresses, however, smells tend to dissipate after in a few days.

Expensive – The Puffy and Zenhaven mattresses are generally considered expensive. A queen-size mattress costs approximately $1,800 respectively.

Poor Edge Support – Neither mattress includes a significant amount of edge support.

Puffy, like most memory foam mattresses does tend to compress too far on its edge making it difficult to get in and out of bed.

Similarly, the Zenhaven mattress is reported to sink and have little to no edge support.

How are Puffy and Zenhaven Mattresses Different?

The Puffy and Zenhaven mattresses are different in significant ways, most of which can be attributed to their respective types.

Mattress Type – The Puffy mattress is a memory foam mattress that consists of two layers of polyfoam that combine to form 10-inches of contouring support.

Puffy Lux models include a third layer of memory foam, adding 2 more inches to its total thickness.

The Puffy mattress also includes a thick polyfoam core that provides additional support and prevents the body from sinking too far into the mattress.

Memory foam contributes to many of the Puffy mattress’s best features, including its contouring support and how well it relieves the symptoms of back pain.

In contrast, the Zenhaven mattress flaunts a latex design, which makes it more responsive, firm and supportive than the Puffy mattress.

Firmness – The firmness of a mattress can be primarily attributed to the mattress type. The same can be said of the Puffy and Zenhaven mattresses.

The Puffy mattress is a memory foam mattress; thus, it is inherently softer than the latex Zenhaven mattress.

The Puffy mattress is considered a six on the firmness scale, whereas the Zenhaven mattress falls between 4 and 7, depending on the side.

Responsiveness – The Zenhaven mattress is the more responsive option due, again to the characteristics of latex construction.

Temperature Neutrality – Temperature neutrality is essential to providing a comfortable sleep surface.

Considering all mattress types, memory foam mattresses are the least effective at providing a cool, temperature neutral sleep surface.

The memory foam used in the Puffy mattress allows the body to sink into the mattress further than the Zenhaven mattress.

When the body sinks into memory foam it is essentially encapsulated in foam which retains heat close to the body.

Hypoallergenic Materials – The Zenhaven mattress is manufactured from all-natural Talalay latex and hypoallergenic.

Sleep Type – The Zenhaven mattress is more likely to be preferential to a more significant number of sleep types than the Puffy mattress.

Though memory foam is generally seen as the most comfortable mattress type amongst most consumers, it is not necessarily beneficial to specific sleep types.

The Zenhaven mattress is the winner regarding the most benefit provided to the most significant number of sleep types.

The Zenhaven mattress conforms to the body and provides a supportive, springy sleep surface, that is beneficial to side, stomach, back and combination sleepers.

Affordable Option – The standard puffy mattress is more affordable than the standard Zenhaven mattress, though the Puffy Lux model is competitively priced with the Zenhaven mattress.

Durability – Latex mattresses are generally more durable than their memory foam counterparts.

Though the Puffy mattress is slightly more durable than most memory foam mattresses, it can’t be expected to last for more than three years of nightly use.

In contrast, the Zenhaven latex mattress can be expected to last at least seven years due to the durable characteristics of latex.

Length of Warranty – The Puffy mattress includes a lifetime warranty, compared to the twenty-year warranty included with the Zenhaven mattress.

And The Winner Is…

ZenHaven! Buy Online Now

We consider the Zenhaven mattress the winner of our mattress showdown of several significant reasons.

Overall Quality – When overall feel is considered the Zenhaven mattress feels more luxurious and comfortable than the Puffy Mattress.

The Zenhaven mattress also features all-natural, hypoallergenic materials and more durable construction.

Temperature Neutrality – The Zenhaven mattress is also inherently better than the puffy mattress concerning temperature neutrality.

The conforming characteristics of memory foam traps heat close to the body and prevents heat from dissipating.

In contrast, the Zenhaven mattress is manufactured from Talalay latex. Latex consists of billions of responsive cells that add breathability, and add support to prevent the body from becoming encapsulated in the mattress.

Customer Satisfaction – Though the Puffy mattress enjoys a celebrity endorsement there is no better endorsement than positive customer feedback.

The Zenhaven is the recipient of thousands of positive customer reviews, not to mention a reputation of continual customer satisfaction and efficient customer support.

Product Selection – The number of mattress options available to Puffy and Zenhaven customers is the same.

Each brand offers two sleep surfaces that appeal to different sleepers, however only Zenhaven offers two firmness options in the same, flippable mattress.

Appeal to Sleep Types – Because the Zenhaven mattress is flippable it is more appealing to a larger number of sleep types than the one-sided Puffy mattress.

Additionally, latex mattresses are generally more compatible with different sleep types due to their responsive, and supportive characteristics.

The Puffy mattress is considered an excellent choice for back, and side sleepers, however, stomach and combination sleepers may find that it is too soft to be completely comfortable.

The firm side of the Zenhaven mattress is compatible with stomach, and back sleepers while the soft side is better suited for side and combination sleepers.

Durability – Due mainly to its latex construction the Zenhaven mattress is more durable than the Puffy mattress, which we feel offsets its shorter warranty.

The lifespan of the Zenhaven mattress is more than double that of the Puffy mattress, not to mention it can be flipped once one side has been degraded from seven or more years of nightly use.

Value – The durability and flippable characteristics of the Zenhaven mattress provide greater overall value than the comparatively priced Puffy Lux mattress.

However, the standard Puffy mattress provides excellent value at half the price of the standard Zenhaven mattress.

As already mentioned, preferential features had to be removed as determining factors from our comparison.

Preference simply plays too large of a roll in determining whether an individual is going to see one mattress type as more comfortable than the other.

However, when preferential features are removed all that remains is the overall value of the mattress, its durability, and its appeal to the largest number of sleep types. In that regard, the Zenhaven is clearly the winner.

  • Quality – Zenhaven
  • Price – Tie
  • Reputation – Puffy
  • Sleep Trial – Zenhaven
  • Warranty – Puffy
  • Customer Support – Zenhaven
  • Product Selection – Zenhaven

For sleepers with specific needs…

Side Sleepers: Puffy

Neck pain is generally associated with side sleeping because of the extra strain that is exerted on the neck. The height of the shoulder prevents the head from resting on the pillow without straining the neck too far in one direction.

The Puffy mattress is the better choice for side sleepers because it absorbs the weight of the shoulder better than the Zenhaven mattress, thus reducing how far the head must travel to contact the pillow.

However, the Zenhaven is not a terrible choice for side sleepers by any means. The soft side of the Zenhaven mattress is soft enough to absorb the shoulder and provide neck pain relief.

Back Pain: Zenhaven

The two features that are the most beneficial to back pain relief is the conforming characteristics of a mattress as well as the firmness of the sleep surface.

Zenhaven is the better choice of mattress for those who suffer from back pain because it is firm enough to provide adequate support, yet it conforms to the shape of the spine enabling a healthy spinal alignment.

Heavy People: Zenhaven

Due to the soft, enveloping characteristics of memory foam, it is not the ideal mattress type for individuals who weigh more than 230 pounds.

Heavier individuals tend to compress memory foam beyond the point where it can provide adequate support. For these reasons, the Puffy memory foam mattress is not considered a good option for heavier sleepers.

In contrast, the firm, springy support provided by the Zenhaven mattress makes it very applicable to heavy sleepers who are less likely to compress the latex beyond the point where it can no longer provide adequate support.

In addition, the Zenhaven mattress includes a supportive core to ensure the body does not sink unevenly and cause stress in sensitive areas of the body like the spine, lower back, hips and shoulders.

Couples: Zenhaven

Motion isolation is often a determining factor for couples deciding on which mattress to purchase. Memory foam mattresses are generally considered to perform better at isolating and dampening motion.

However, the motion isolation offered by the latex Zenhaven mattress is exceptional, even when compared to memory foam mattresses.

Additionally, the springy and responsive characteristics of latex make it the better mattress type for sex. When these features are combined, the Zenhaven mattress is the clear choice for couples.


The Zenhaven mattress outperforms the Puffy mattress in several non-preferential areas including temperature neutrality, durability, product selection, back pain relief and the benefit it provides for the most significant number of sleep types.

It should be noted that preference is the ultimate determining factor in any mattress decision.

The Puffy mattress is a phenomenal mattress that maintains one of the best customer satisfaction levels in the industry. The Puffy mattress is conforming, supportive, and not at all expensive when considering the standard model.

The Zenhaven mattress is built to last, and an excellent choice for any sleep type, even couples and combination sleepers, and ultimately, overall value is the determining factor of any consumer comparison.

Similar Posts