Puffy vs. Stearns & Foster Mattress Comparison 2022 : Which Is Better?

View The Winner

In the red corner, weighing in with a lifetime warranty and claiming the title of “the internet’s most comfortable mattress” is the universally comfortable mattress from Puffy. In the blue corner, competing to test Puffy’s claim to fame is the Heracles of hybrids, Stearns & Foster.

Our showdown will consist of a battle over comfort, price, quality, warranty and customer satisfaction. Both competitors already maintain reputations for quality and comfort, but which one will edge out the other for the title of winner?

About The Brands

Before we begin the head to head bout for mattress dominance, let’s take a closer look at our contenders.

The Puffy Lux Mattress

Puffy developed their mattress with the goal of creating a bed that is absurdly comfortable, no matter the individual who sleeps on it.

Puffy designed their mattress with deep restorative sleep in mind, so they stuffed it full of advanced conforming memory foam to induce the deepest, most restorative sleep possible.

The Puffy mattress features an all foam construction designed to contour and conform to the body, relieve pressure points and support proper spinal alignment.

The Puffy mattress has been called the internet’s most comfortable mattress because it is one of the most highly rated mattresses according to customer reviews.

Puffy seems to have earned those reviews as four years of research went into crafting a mattress that can be universally comfortable to the broadest array of sleepers, yet still provide the support needed to align the spine and relieve painful pressure points.

The Puffy mattress has been celebrated by lighter individuals, as well as stomach and side sleepers for its firmness, enveloping feel, and support for healthy spinal alignment.

Stearns & Foster Mattress Collection

Stearns & Foster maintains a reputation for luxury and offers an array of different mattress options.

Stearns & Foster mattresses feature a hybrid construction enabling them to combine the best aspects of foam and innerspring mattresses. Stearns & Foster mattresses also feature pocketed coils and gel-infused memory which is designed to be universally comfortable for back, side and stomach sleepers.

The Stearns & Foster mattress collection consists of 4 mattress models that are available in an array of thicknesses, levels of firmness and size.

  • Estate- Consists of three layers of memory foam and a core of polyfoam encased pocketed inner coils
  • Lux Estate- Includes a three-layer system comprised of memory foam support layer, pillowtop top layer and a base layer of gel-infused memory foam.
  • Lux Estate Hybrid- features three layers of memory foam supported by a core of polyfoam encased pocketed inner coils.
  • Reserve- Features four comfort components centered around a core of polyfoam encased pocketed inner coils, hybrid pillow top layer, standard pillow top, gel-infused memory foam, and a high-density foam base.

The Stearns & Foster mattress has been praised by heavier individuals and those who sleep on their back for the mattresses firmness, edge support and deep support which make it easy to get in and out of bed, firm enough to prevent too much sink, and comfortable enough to relieve pressure on the hips, lumbar shoulders and spine.

Puffy Recap Full Review

Why To Like:

  • Superb motion isolation.
  • Comes with a lifetime warranty.
  • Affordably priced.
  • Free delivery
ALSO READ:  Casper vs. Purple Mattress Comparison 2022 : Which Is Better?

Why To Doubt

  • Edge support is poor.
  • Limited to one firmness option.
  • Tendency to sleep warm.

Stearns & Foster Recap Full Review

Why To Like

  • Reputation for luxury.
  • Edge support is strong.
  • Superb motion isolation.
  • Available in multiple thickness options.

Why To Doubt

  • Heavy, difficult to install.
  • The mattress is expensive.
  • No sleep trial

Puffy and Stearns & Foster Comparison

How are Puffy and Stearns & Foster Similar?

Comparing the Puffy and Stearns & Foster mattresses reveals few similarities. Excluding specific features and materials such as the inclusion of memory foam, the only similarities evident between the two contenders are in the inclusion of a warranty and their reputation for customer satisfaction.

Both mattresses are manufactured from quality materials and score high in motion isolation, support, and comfort. However, due to their memory foam construction, both mattresses will sleep warmer the comparable hybrid and latex mattresses.

Both mattresses also include memory foam, which provides conforming comfort and support but also contributes to a warmer mattress. In this regard, the Puffy and Stearns & Foster mattresses both performed fair in temperature neutrality.

  • Motion Isolation- Both the Stearns & Foster and Puffy mattresses offer high levels of motion isolation due to their inclusion of conforming, memory foam.
  • Warranty- Both the Puffy and Stearns & Foster mattresses offer comprehensive warranties.
  • Reputation- The Puffy and Stearns & Foster mattresses both maintain a reputation for exceptional comfort and catering to a large array of different sleep types.
  • Customer Support- Customers of both Puffy and Stearns & Foster overwhelmingly report positive experiences in dealing with either companies customer service.

How are Puffy and Stearns & Foster Different?

The Puffy and Stearns & Foster mattresses are very different mattresses. The mattresses share few similarities in regard to price, durability, sleep trial, product selection, type, design, and their specific features.

Though both mattresses include memory foam in their construction, the way the two mattresses implement memory foam into the design and function of the mattress vary drastically.

The Puffy Lux mattress features a triple layer, memory foam construction which includes a poly foam core. The layers are specially designed to comfortably envelope the body, yet remain firm enough to prevent the body from sinking too far into the mattress and causing discomfort.

The Stearns & Foster mattresses, on the other hand, combines pocketed inner coils, memory foam, gel infused memory foam, side vents, and a Stretch-knit Tencel lyocell Blend cover to provide a cool, supportive, yet exceptionally comfortable mattress.

Though customers report greater spinal alignment and back pain relief with the Puffy mattress, customers report higher edge support and a more luxurious feel with the Stearns & Foster mattress.

Sleep Trial- There is an obvious difference between the two mattresses in terms of sleep trial, only the Puffy mattress offer one. Puffy offers a 101-day sleep trial wherein customers can return the mattress for a full refund, should they be unsatisfied with the mattress in any way.

Stearns & Foster offers no such sleep trial.

Warranty- Though both mattresses offer fairly comprehensive warranties, only Puffy offers a lifetime warranty, wherein they will “repair or replace all mattress defects for as long as the owner retains possession of the mattress.”

Stearns & Foster offers a ten-year limited warranty which is dependent on mattresses size and model as well as the collection from which it is selected.

Edge Support- The Stearns & Foster mattress maintains higher levels of edge support than the puffy mattress which makes it easier to get in and out of bed.

Product Selection- Stearns and Foster offers far more product selection than Puffy. The Puffy mattress is available in only one firmness option and two models: The puffy, and the Puffy Lux.

ALSO READ:  Casper vs. GhostBed Mattress Comparison 2022 : Which Is Better?

Stearns & Foster offers four collections (Estate, Lux Estate, Lux Hybrid, and Reserve) wherein customers can choose a mattress from various combinations of thickness, size, model and feature.

Quality- Customers report higher levels of quality in the Puffy mattress than in the Stearns & Foster mattress.

The Stearns and Foster mattress provides a higher level of edge support than the Puffy mattress. However, the customers also report a high level of sag and early deterioration, which is unfortunate considering the high price of a Stearns and Foster mattress.

Price- Concerning price and affordability the two mattresses could not be more different. The Puffy mattress is more affordable than the Stearns & Foster, by far.

A queen Puffy Lux mattress can be purchased for approximately $950, whereas a queen Stearns & Foster mattress can range from $1500 to $3500 depending on which collection the mattress is selected.

Furthermore, Stearns & Foster operates no brick and mortar store locations which makes it difficult to offer free delivery.

And The Winner Is…

The Puffy Mattress! Buy Online Now

We’re confident in recommending the Puffy Lux Mattress as the best choice based on our analysis of key factors that an average, discerning mattress shopper would care most about.

Higher Quality: Both mattresses exhibited the use of high-quality materials and, in general, feels as though you’re sleeping on a mattress that is well constructed, supportive and designed to be universally comfortable. However, that is where the quality similarities end between the two mattresses.

The Puffy mattress is not only more comfortable than the Stearns & Foster mattress, but it also

exhibited no signs of early deterioration with lighter individuals and performed fairly well at accommodating heavier sleepers.

The Stearns & Foster mattress, on the other hand, exhibited premature sagging and deterioration much sooner than the Puffy mattress.

Customer Support: Furthermore, Puffy offers free delivery on any of their mattresses. Stearns & Foster offers no such delivery options, which is disconcerting considering that the Stearns & Foster mattress is exceptionally heavy, bulky, and difficult to maneuver into place.

Longer Sleep Trial: The 101-night sleep trial included with the Puffy mattress is also superior to the Stearns & Foster mattress not for the length of the sleep trial, but for the simple fact that Stearns & Foster doesn’t offer one.

Lifetime Warranty: The warranty offered by the Puffy mattress is also superior to Stearns & Foster because it extends for the life of the mattress, regardless of circumstance.

The Stearns & Foster mattress has a reputation amongst customers for sagging and early deterioration, yet it only comes with a ten year, very limited warranty.

Affordable Price: All the ways in which the Puffy mattress is superior to the Stearns & Foster mattress would typically indicate that it would be the more expensive mattress; however, that is not the case.

The Puffy mattress is far more affordable than every mattress model offered by Stearns & Foster. In some instances, the Stearns & Foster mattress costs more than double the cost of the Puffy Mattress.

Product Selection: The Puffy mattress seems to accomplish in two mattress options what Stearns and Foster fails to accomplish in 4 collections of mattresses that come in a wide variety of sizes, thicknesses and firmness levels.

  • Quality – Stearns & Foster
  • Price – Puffy
  • Reputation – Puffy
  • Sleep Trial – Puffy
  • Warranty – Puffy
  • Customer Support – Puffy
  • Product Selection – Stearns & Foster

For sleepers with specific needs…

Side Sleepers: Puffy Lux Mattress

Side sleepers generally report pain in the neck and shoulders. This is often due to the large gap created between the head and the surface of the mattress when lying on one’s side.

The puffy mattress is ideal for side sleepers when compared to the Stearns & Foster mattress because the Puffy mattress allows for the body to sink into the mattress, thus reducing how far the head has to strain before reaching the support of the pillow.

ALSO READ:  Casper vs. Saatva Mattress Comparison 2022 : Which Is Better?

However, the same can not be said for heavier sleepers over 230 pounds. The Puffy mattress only ranks as “fair” for heavier side sleepers. In contrast, the Stearns & Foster mattress is reported to provide more support and comfort for heavier individuals who sleep on their side.

Stomach Sleepers: Puffy Lux Mattress

Stomach sleepers will also benefit from the Puffy Lux Mattress due to the bed’s combination of firmness and enveloping sink.

The Puffy mattress manages to be firm enough to support the hips, knees, and chest while stomach sleeping, yet soft enough to enable sleepers to sleep with a pillow under their hips, as is so often the case with stomach sleepers.

Back Pain: Stearns & Foster Lux Estate

When comparing the Stearns & Foster mattress to the Puffy mattress Stearns & Foster proved to be the more comfortable mattress for back sleepers.

Back sleepers report “good” and “very good” when asked about how comfortable the Stearns & Foster mattress felt when sleeping and how well it supported and aligned the spine.

The Stearns & Foster Lux Estate mattress is firm, conforming and includes pocketed inner coils to provide additional support. All things that contribute to a comfortable night’s rest for back sleepers.

Heavy People: Stearns & Foster Lux Estate

The Stearns & Foster Lux Estate mattress is the better mattress for heavy people when compared to the Puffy mattress for the same reasons it is beneficial for back sleepers.

It is firm, yet conforming which means it can support additional weight while remaining comfortable.

The Stearns & Foster Lux Estate is also overly thick, supported by pocketed inner coils and ventilated.

These features enable the Stearns & Foster Lux Estate mattress to comfortably envelop a heavier individual yet remain supportive of the spine, relieve pressure points and regulate temperature, so it remains cool all evening long.

Furthermore, the Stearns & Foster Lux Estate mattress has been thoroughly reviewed to have exceptional edge support which makes it easier for sleepers to get in and out of bed, especially individuals who may be overweight.

Couples: Stearns & Foster Lux Estate

The pocketed inner coils and inclusion of conforming memory foam in the Stearns & Foster Lux Estate mattress also make it better suited for couples.

The mattress is mildly firm and conforming which means it comfortably accommodates two sleepers, and different sleep types simultaneously.

The pocketed inner springs also provide the Stearns & Foster Lux Estate with a healthy amount of spring and responsiveness which positively impacts sex.

However, the mattress also includes solid edge support and performs exceptionally well at isolating and damping motion, which means that sleepers stand less of a chance of waking their partner when moving or getting in and out of bed.


The Puffy mattress is the clear winner over the Stearns & Foster mattress collection for its exceptional support and comfort, but also for the wide array of sleep types it can accommodate.

However, the Stearns & Foster mattress is not without its qualities. When considering the benefits provided to specific sleep needs, and individual sleep types the Stearns & Foster mattress excels.

When it comes to value and determining the overall winner of our mattress comparison showdown is the Puffy mattress.

It’s price, customer support, sleep trial and lifetime warranty tell us, the consumer that; “we want your business, we care about your satisfaction with our product, and we are willing to fix it for free should anything happen to it.”

Similar Posts