Sleep Guide is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. In addition, we occasionally receive free product in exchange for our honest opinion. Learn more

View The Winner

To be considered the winner of our head-to-head comparison a mattress must be as durable as it is comfortable, and as supportive as it is affordable.

It must appeal to a large range of sleep types and also include a sleep trial and warranty that puts other brands to shame.

The competition is fierce, and the mattresses comfortable, but only one mattress brand provides enough comfort and support to claim victory.

About the Brands

Puffy Recap Full Review

The Puffy mattress brand proudly claims the title of the internet’s most comfortable mattress, as well as some powerful celebrity endorsements.

Customers can’t stop raving about the cloud-like feel of sleeping on a Puffy mattress and claim that they have never received a more comfortable and restorative nights rest with any other mattress brand.

Why To Like

  • Reduced motion transfer
  • Minimal off-gassing
  • Multiple product options
  • Temperature neutral

Why To Doubt

  • Low degree of edge support
  • Less affordable than similar brands.

Purple Recap Full Review

The Purple mattress is innovating the entire mattress industry with its inclusion of a unique and patented Smart Grid Technology which not only provides comfort and support but increases airflow, and eliminates motion transfer.

Why To Like

  • Prevents overheating
  • Innovative hybrid design
  • Multiple product options
  • Pain relieving

Why To Doubt

  • Heavy and awkward to move in place
  • Not particularly affordable

Puffy and Purple Comparison

How are Puffy And Purple Mattresses Similar?

The similarities between the Puffy and Purple mattress are found in the effectiveness of their design and the raving reviews of their customers.

Motion Isolation- Both the Purple & Puffy mattresses include high levels of motion isolation, as they both are constructed with multiple conforming and weight dispersing layers that isolate and dampen motion.

Ideal for Couples- The Purple and Puffy mattress brands perform equally well with couples who cite superior motion isolation as a key factor in their decision. With the Purple and Puffy mattresses, couples needn’t worry about disturbing their sleep partner when getting in and out of bed.

Conforming- The Purple and Puffy mattresses, though different in material and construction are both considered conforming mattresses, as both contours to the shape of the body when weight is exerted on the mattress surface.

Temperature Neutral- Though the conforming effect tends to cause a mattress to overheat, the Puffy and Purple mattresses include features designed to prevent overheating and keep the mattress and a cool, neutral temperature.

Relieves Back Pain- A conforming mattress does not always coincide with back pain relief, however in regards to the Purple and Puffy mattress the contouring nature of the materials used provides comfortable support for all the most sensitive areas of the spine, hips, lower back, and neck.

Edge Support- Neither the Purple nor Puffy mattress provides a decent level of edge support which is a commonly reported flaw of conforming mattresses and due to the softer materials used in their construction.

Product Selection- The Purple and Puffy mattress brands both offer a different selection of mattress models, which is more than can be said of most memory foam and hybrid mattress brands.

Sleep Trial- The sleep trials offered with the Purple and Puffy mattress are virtually identical. Each mattress comes with a 100-night sleep trial in which customers can return the mattress for a full refund, no questions asked.

Free Delivery- Additionally, both the Purple and Puffy mattresses are available for purchase online and include free delivery to anywhere in the lower 48 states.

How are Puffy And Purple Mattresses Different?

At first glance, the Puffy and Purple mattresses appear very similar. It is only after the outer cover is removed, and the internal construction revealed that the differences are made apparent.

Design & Construction- Removing the outer cover of the Purple and Puffy mattresses reveals the variations in their design and the materials used in their construction.

The Puffy mattress consists of two individual layers of memory foam that combine to provide cooling, supportive comfort.

The first layer consists of three-inches of conforming Cooling Cloud foam which is designed to wick away heat and increase airflow, thus maintaining a cool and comfortable sleep temperature.

The second layer of the Puffy mattress consists of a seven-inch thick Firm Core Support foam which serves to provide deep, contouring support for the entire body.

The Purple mattress, on the other hand, incorporates an innovative design that is also the defining feature of the Purple mattress.

The Purple mattress features a two-inch thick Smart-Comfort Grid manufactured from a hyper-elastic polymer. The Smart-Comfort Grid’s unique design comfortably absorbs and redistributes body weight to relieve pressure points, contour the body and provide healthy spinal alignment.

The Smart-Comfort Grid layer is supported by two more layers of memory foam which provide a firm base and the density to support deep compression of the top layer.

Materials- Though both the Purple and Puffy mattresses include memory foam in their construction; only the Purple mattress features the hyper-elastic polymer used to manufacture the Smart-Comfort Grid.

Durability- The Purple mattress is the more durable option when compared to the Puffy mattress as the hyper-elastic polymer used in the construction of the Smart-Comfort Grid is exceptionally tough and immune to most forms of wear and tear.

The Puffy mattress is constructed from a comparatively low-density material and as such does not hold up to extended use, especially for heavier individuals who exert more weight on the mattress.

Mattress Type- The Puffy and Purple brands produce a different type of mattress. The Puffy mattress only incorporates memory foam materials which firmly places it in the memory foam category.

However, the Purple mattress is considered a hybrid mattress as it incorporates memory foam and hyper-elastic polymer into its design.

Affordability- The Puffy and Purple mattresses are evenly priced. However, a queen-size  Puffy mattress is more affordable than a queen-size Purple mattress, and the difference in price only grows with the size of the mattress.

Warranty- The Puffy mattress includes a better warranty than the Purple mattress. Puffy extends a lifetime warranty over their product whereas Purple only extends a ten-year limited warranty.

And The Winner Is…

The Purple Mattress Buy Online Now

We’re confident recommending the Purple Mattress as the best choice based on our analysis of key factors that an average, discerning mattress shopper would care most about.

The Smart-Comfort Grid of the Purple mattress is the real winner of our comparison because of the impressive way it redistributes body weight while still providing conforming comfort and support.

The Smart-Comfort Grid contours to the body, aligning the spine into a neutral position and relieving back pain so that sleepers experience a more restorative night of rest.

What’s more, the grid layout of the hyper-elastic polymer is responsive and amplifies airflow, so the Purple mattress not only remains cool all night long, it remains supportive and prevents the body from sinking too far into the mattress.

The hyper-elastic polymer of the Smart-Comfort Grid is also more durable than the comparatively low-density memory foam used in the Puffy mattress. For the same reason, the Purple mattress is also the better choice for heavier individuals.

The Puffy mattress is more likely to sustain wear and tear, and not provide enough deep support for sleepers who weigh more than 230 pounds.

The Purple mattress also offers a wider product selection than the Puffy mattress compared to the two models offered by Puffy. The Purple mattress comes in four separate models including Purple, New Purple 11”, New Purple 12”, New Purple 13”.

It’s true that the Purple mattress is the slightly more expensive mattress when compared to the Puffy mattress; however, the high level of support and comfort provided by its innovative design is worth the extra cost in price.

The Puffy mattress includes a more comprehensive warranty. However; the Purple mattress compensates for its limited warranty with a longer predicted lifespan and increase resistance to wear and tear.

The Purple mattress is the overall winner of our head-to-head comparison because, of the two mattresses, it provides the most comfort and support for the widest range of sleep types.

The Puffy mattress, though comfortable and supportive for side and back sleepers, is not going to provide the same comfort and support for those who sleep on their stomachs, or individuals who weigh more than 230 pounds.

  • Quality – Purple
  • Price – Puffy
  • Reputation – Purple
  • Sleep Trial – Tie
  • Warranty – Puffy
  • Customer Support – Purple
  • Product Selection – Purple

For sleepers with specific needs…

Side Sleepers: The Puffy Mattress

A common complaint amongst side sleepers is the additional pain in the neck and shoulders caused by the drastic gap in space between the head and the surface of the mattress when lying on one’s side.

The Puffy mattress is the better choice of mattress for side sleepers for the same reason that makes it a less desirable choice for those who sleep on their stomach or back.

The lower-density memory foam used in the construction of the Puffy mattress allows the body to sink further into the surface of the mattress, thus reducing the amount of space the head must clear before resting on the pillow.

By relieving the strain on the neck, the Puffy mattress further aligns the body and supports a more natural spinal position.

Stomach Sleepers: The Purple Mattress

According to the Mayo Clinic, sleeping on the stomach causes the natural curve of the spine to flatten, this can cause pain in the lower back and stiffness in the hips and shoulders.

The human body accumulates most of its weight in the middle, which makes it difficult for the spine to remain neutral while laying down. Sleeping on the stomach does nothing to support a neutral spine and may actually exacerbate any pain that you already feel.

The Purple mattress is the better mattress for stomach sleepers when compared to the Puffy mattress because it provides a firmer sleep surface.

Stomach sleeping is the least beneficial sleep position for the body because it often leads to poor spinal alignment and additional strain exerted on the neck, hips and lower back.

The Puffy mattress does not provide enough deep support to elevate the hips properly, so the spine remains in a neutral position. The Purple mattress, on the other hand evenly distributes weight and remains firm enough to prevent any part of the body from sinking too far into the mattress.

What’s more, the Purple mattress also includes an additional layer of support which ensures that the mattress remains firm, and does not sag at any point during the night.

Back Pain: The Purple Mattress

For relieving back pain, some would argue that few mattresses compare to the Purple mattress.

Once again, the secret to the Purple mattresses success is in its patented Smart-Comfort Grid design and the use of the hyper-elastic polymer.

The Smart-Comfort Grid is specially designed to distribute the weight of the sleeper evenly and to contour to the shape of the body. The resulting effect is full pressure point relief.

For the same reasons, the Purple mattress is also the better choice of mattress for those who sleep on their back.

Heavy People: The Purple Mattress

Memory foam mattresses are considered the least comfortable mattress for heavier individuals because they are missing the deep compression support that heavier individuals often require.

Those who weigh more than 230 pounds will often compress a memory foam mattress beyond any level of support it can provide.

The Purple mattress is considered a hybrid and as such can seemingly accomplish the impossible; It remains firm, yet conforms, it’s springy, yet it provides deep compression support and remains temperature neutral.

These features are the result of the hyper-elastic polymer Smart-Comfort Grid which quickly responds to a change in position, increases airflow and provides supporting comfort for the spine regardless of weight.

Thus the Purple mattress is the better choice for heavier individuals because it evenly distributes weight and enables the body to remain supported even when depressed to its maximum compression.

Couples: The Purple Mattress

The Purple mattress is a terrific mattress choice for couples because it provides superb motion isolation, yet allows for just enough responsive spring to benefit sexual activity.

In fact, couples who sleep on the Purple Mattress report the most significant reduction in motion transfer of any other mattress.

The Smart-Comfort Grid system it provides nominal support and pressure relief for both of sleepers regardless of individual sleep postures, or how frequently sleep partners change position throughout the night.

The Smart-Grid comfort layer of the Purple mattress increases airflow and ensure the mattress remains cool throughout the entire night which is especially beneficial for couples whose mattress must compensate for twice the amount of body heat.

What’s more, the Purple mattress appeals to more than one sleep type and can cater to the needs of two sleep types simultaneously.

Conclusion

The Puffy and Purple mattresses perform exceptionally well and are a favorite of the internet and TV advertising; however, it is only the Purple mattress that combines the best features of memory foam and supportive latex to appeal to the greatest number of sleep types and individuals.

In fact, the Purple mattress is the only mattress that we have seen that can rival the reputation and popularity of the Puffy mattress, which has received more than one celebrity endorsement.

We consider the Purple mattress the winner of the side-by-side comparison because of its unique and innovative hybrid design.

The incorporation of the hyper-elastic polymer Smart-Comfort Grid is the key to the continued success, and raving customer reviews of the Purple mattress.

Though the Purple mattress is more expensive and does not include a lifetime warranty, we suspect it is hardly ever needed as the properties of the hyper-elastic polymer make it more durable than standard memory foam.

Most importantly is the level of support and comfort that the Purple mattress provides, for the largest array of sleep types. The Purple mattress appeals to many and is rarely considered a bad choice for any sleep type.

The Puffy and Purple mattresses are not available in-store and can only be purchased online, however, they both include home delivery, and neither includes a particularly strong off-gassing odor.

Additionally, both the Purple and Puffy mattress brands are considered “affordable” when compared to similar mattress brands. In fact, the Purple mattress is the most affordable hybrid mattress currently on the market.

However; regardless of sleep type and mattress preference, the most important comparison we can make is in the level of comfort that is provided by either mattress.

In that regard, both the Puffy and Purple mattresses excel to the front of the pack and do so for much less than the competition.

Tim

Remember how your parents told you that you were going to sleep your life away? Well that would be perfectly fine with Tim. He's been in search of the most comfortable nights sleep for years and shares his findings with any willing ear.

View all posts

Add comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Sleep Like a Baby

Get tips, tricks and product recommendations to help you sleep through the night.

You're in! As a thank you enjoy $25 Off Our Favorite Pillow.

Pin It on Pinterest