Puffy vs. Loom & Leaf Mattress Comparison 2022 : Which Is Better?

View The Winner

Two all foam mattresses from two mattress industry disruptors. One comes from a company already established with a supportive hybrid. One was seen recently on Ellen. Which one might be your next mattress?

Before you get all starry-eyed about Ellen (and yes, we love her too), let’s break down each mattress in our Puffy versus Loom & Leaf matchup. Puffy will win some battles. Loom & Leaf will win others. Which one will come out the top pick? Let’s take a look.

About The Brands

A few things before we start.

Puffy Recap Full Review

Why To Like

  • excellent budget option
  • suitable temperature regulation
  • a two layer or three layer option
  • lifetime warranty

Why To Doubt

  • less trial period than Loom & Leaf
  • not all organic materials

Loom & Leaf Recap Full Review

Why To Like

  • mostly organic materials
  • two different firmness options
  • no off-gassing
  • free white glove delivery

Why To Doubt

  • more expensive than Puffy
  • 15-year warranty (Puffy is lifetime)

Puffy and Loom & Leaf Comparison

Although the mattresses both use foam to create contouring and support layers, they aren’t exactly the same. Let’s take a look at what they do have in common first.

How are Puffy And Loom & Leaf Similar?

Both Puffy and Loom & Leaf rely on different densities of foam to provide a good night’s sleep. While they aren’t exactly the same, here are a few things you can find in both companies.

Contouring And Support

Old styles of mattresses were great at support and terrible at contouring. They forced your body to conform to the surface of the bed rather than the other way around. Your shoulders and hips compressed and your spine twisted out of place.

Soft mattresses were the opposite. They gave out underneath you, causing huge sagging and forcing your spine out of alignment. Your back never got the chance to decompress because it was so busy trying to keep your body together.

Both Puffy and Loom & Leaf use a series of layers with varying densities to address both of these issues. The contouring layer or layers on top give way underneath your broadest points, so your shoulders or hips sink further into the mattress. The foam fills in gaps around your waist and lower lumbar region while supporting your legs.

Underneath the contouring layers, support layers made of dense foam push back against your body to provide support. It keeps your spine aligned and prevents your body from sagging too far into the mattress. The result? Your spine stays in a similar position that it would if you were upright. No twisting. No overextending.

Edge Support

Memory foam mattresses have a terrible reputation for collapsing towards the sides. Both Puffy and Loom & Leaf have good edge support.

You can sleep all the way to the edges of the mattress without feeling like you’re losing support or sliding off. If you’re one half of a couple, you’re able to use the entire bed without sliding off. No one has to fight over the sweet spot.

You can use the edge of the bed to sit down. Tying your shoes? It can handle it. Sitting on the side of the bed just after the alarm goes off and pondering your life choices and “just how bad do you need this job?” They can’t answer that question, but they can support you while you decide.

ALSO READ:  Casper vs. Tempurpedic Mattress Comparison 2022 : Which Is Better?

Motion Transfer

Memory foam is excellent at isolating motion. If your giant dog, the love of your life, is fond of scratching at 2:00 a.m. when you’re trying to sleep for your presentation the next morning, good news. You won’t feel it.

If your partner turns into a giant wildebeest during his or her dreams, you won’t feel that either. The foam dampens the movement, so your side of the bed stays peaceful.

Another benefit of motion isolation is that no one causes a dip in the mattress for being heavier. It’s rare that both partners are the same weight and even a minor weight difference can cause a dip in some beds.

Neither of these does that, so both partners get a smooth, pristine surface to sleep. You won’t roll towards each other in the middle of the night (unless you want to).

Temperature Regulation

Memory foam has a reputation for feeling like hot quicksand. Old memory foams weren’t very breathable, so they stored heat from your body in the core of the mattress and reflected it back to you throughout the night. Not so comfortable.

Both mattresses use a combination of materials meant to be breathable and improve airflow. Puffy’s top layer is something called Cloud Comfort. The material actively wicks heat and moisture away from the surface of the mattress where it can dissipate.

Loom & Leaf also uses gel-infused foams with open cell memory foam. For both mattresses, as you move around, air is forced through tiny air pockets causing heat to dissipate and moisture to dry. Puffy has a slight edge with cooling, but both mattresses do sleep cooler.

If your ambient room temperature is hot, the mattresses aren’t going to make you feel any cooler than you already are. Open cell memory foams and gel infusions help the mattress return to ambient room temperature sooner than ordinary memory foam.

Manufacturing And Customer Service

Both companies manufacture their mattress in the United States, so there aren’t any long wait times for shipping (unless you’re an international buyer). If it’s essential for you to purchase US made products, these both check that box.

They don’t specify where their customer service agents are located, but both appear to have representatives in the US as well. You shouldn’t experience any language or comprehension issues.

Both have customer service that’s quick and helpful. If you have an issue, it’s taken care of politely and quickly.

Social Initiatives

Both companies are highly involved in social initiatives. Puffy donates a mattress to local homeless shelters that house children and teens particularly. They organize around the hashtag #jumpforkids.

Loom & Leaf also donates mattresses to organizations that work with housing and homelessness initiatives. They donate over 250 mattresses each year for different causes including Hurricane Sandy relief efforts.

How are Puffy And Loom & Leaf Different?

There are a few differences in the makeup of their materials and logistics like sleep trials and shipping.

Puffy Models

Puffy makes two different mattresses, the original Puffy and the Luxe.


The original uses two layers of foams. The first is a Cloud Comfort layer intended to be more contouring than regular memory foam. It’s open cell and infused with gel for a cooler experience. It’s highly breathable and relieves pressure on all your joints.

The dense support layer uses Puffy’s Firm Core Support to push back against your body to keep your spine aligned. It adapts to your body, encouraging proper circulation and pressure relief. It discourages tossing and turning so your sleep is more restful.

It rates about a six on a ten point firmness scale.

Puffy Luxe

The Luxe uses three different layers of cooling foams to create a uniquely comfortable mattress. It uses the same cloud comfort layer on top with a transitional foam layer of further gel-infused foams. It conforms to your body as you change positions, relieving pressure and keeping your sleep surface cooler.

ALSO READ:  Casper vs. GhostBed Mattress Comparison 2022 : Which Is Better?

The bottom layer is a core support layer, offering more support than standard memory foam mattresses. It’s rated between a five and a half to a seven on the ten point scale. It’s highly supportive with more contouring layers than the original. It feels softer without losing support.

Loom & Leaf

Loom & Leaf is part of Saatva company. It uses organic cotton and a natural thistle flame-retardant layer to create an ultra-soft exterior. The first layer is a Spinal Zone, gel infused foam that conforms to your body and allows shoulders and hips to sink further in. It keeps your spine aligned in the same position as when you’re upright.

The next layer is a premium memory foam layer that begins to transition your body to the support layers underneath. It gives the mattress structural integrity and edge support. Underneath, alternating layers of foam provide progressive support throughout the night.

You have the choice of two different firmness levels. The Loom & Leaf Relaxed Firm rates about a six on the ten point scale while the Firm is an eight.

Eco-Friendly Materials

Puffy’s foams are certified by CertiPur-US, so they are low emission and don’t give off large amounts of VOCs. There may be a slight odor when you open the package, but for most people, the smell dissipates with a little airing out.

Loom & Leaf is made of all eco-friendly materials. There’s virtually no off-gassing, and your mattress is delivered without packing and compression. They’re certified by CertiPur-US and are partners with the Sustainable Furnishings Council

Sleep Trial And Warranty

Puffy gives you 101 nights to try the mattress out before deciding if it’s the right one. Loom & Leaf gives you 120 nights.

Make sure you give your new mattress at least 30 or so nights to allow the bed to break in and your body to adjust. It can take time for old pain to subside and the true support and contouring of each mattress to work.

For both, initiate a return at any time before the trial period is over for a refund. Both companies will attempt to donate the mattress or recycle it.

Puffy gives you a lifetime warranty against mattress defects. You shouldn’t see any sagging or indentations, and there should be no abnormal wear and tear. Contact the company if this happens.

Loom & Leaf offers a 15-year warranty against defects. The rules are the same. You shouldn’t see any abnormal sagging, indentations, or wear and tear. The company will replace any mattresses that show these signs.

Make sure your mattress is adequately supported and that you aren’t using the bed for anything other than its intended purpose, or you may accidentally void the warranty.


Puffy mattresses are compressed when you order and shipped directly to your house. They arrive at your door in a small(ish) box. There’s no need to be home or to sign for the mattress. The delivery person won’t be available to help you set up or remove your old bed, so make arrangements beforehand if you need help.

Unpack the box and gently tear the plastic away from the mattress. It should take a few hours, but the mattress will inflate entirely and be ready for use.

Loom & Leaf doesn’t compress their mattresses because the integrity of the support layer would be compromised. Instead, it ships with complementary white glove delivery. The delivery person arrives at a predetermined time and helps you set up the room if you need to. Loom & Leaf also removes your old mattress for free if you choose that option at checkout.


Both of these mattresses are excellent options, so we think that the price might be the deciding factor.

The original Puffy is $1350 or less for all sizes. The largest size is Cal King ($1350), and it goes down to a twin ($795).

The Puffy Luxe is a little more of an investment at $1795 for a California king down to $1445 for a twin.

ALSO READ:  Leesa vs. Tempurpedic Mattress Comparison 2022 : Which Is Better?

Loom & Leaf is even more of an investment at $1699 for a California king but just $749 for a twin. Those prices are the same regardless of the firmness level you choose.

All of these options are still much cheaper than many showroom mattresses.

And The Winner Is…

Puffy! Buy Online Now

We’re confident in recommending Puffy as the best choice based on our analysis of key factors that an average, discerning mattress shopper would care most about.

Both Loom & Leaf and Puffy create quality mattresses with excellent materials, but Puffy has the edge in the warranty and price categories. It’s tough to argue with a lifetime warranty when most other categories are comparable.

We’d never discourage you from spending money on your health and wellbeing, but we think that the price difference doesn’t necessarily mean more value. Loom & Leaf does use more natural materials, but Puffy’s materials are outstanding quality and produce few emissions of any kind. All things equal, the price is the deciding factor here.

Quality – Tie

Price – Puffy

Reputation – Loom & Leaf

Sleep Trial – Loom & Leaf

Warranty – Puffy

Customer Support – Puffy

Product Selection – Puffy

For sleepers with specific needs…

Side Sleepers: Choose Puffy Luxe

Here’s why… The Puffy Luxe option is one of the softest. It will allow your broadest points to sink further into the mattress while supporting the curves such as your waist or lower lumbar region. It will still provide proper support but accommodate your curves.

Stomach Sleepers: Loom & Leaf Firm

Here’s why… This is definitely the firmest option of all the choices. It rates about an eight on the firmness scale, so there’s very little give in the mattress. Stomach sleepers need a firmer surface to keep the spine from overextending.

Back Pain: Choose Puffy Original

Here’s why… The original is medium-firm which is great for back sleepers who need some contouring. It’s got plenty of support, but the contouring layers will discourage tossing and turning, something that can make back pain worse.

Heavy People: Choose Neither

Honestly, we can’t recommend either mattress for heavier people. There are mattresses out there that can take your specific needs into consideration (Consider Winkbeds Plus or Ghostbed as a start), but neither of these mattresses will support much weight over 300 pounds.

Here’s why…Both mattresses will lose support, and you won’t get the full benefit of the contouring layers either. It’s better if you look elsewhere for your bed.

Couples: Choose Puffy Luxe

Here’s why… The Puffy Luxe is one of the most cooling mattresses available. It should mitigate the effects of two people sleeping in the same bed without everything overheating.

It has excellent motion isolation, so you won’t feel each other moving around, but Puffy’s proprietary foam is more responsive than traditional memory foam, so you should get a little bounce for couple’s activities.


Both Puffy and Loom & Leaf make excellent products, but Puffy wins our matchup. It gives you excellent materials, proper temperature regulation, and an excellent warranty for a smaller price than the Loom & Leaf.

If you’re very particular about your organic materials or you have especially sensitive allergies, Loom & Leaf might be a better option because of their concentration on using as many organic products as possible. Also, because it ships stable, you won’t have the trapped odors the way you do with a compressed mattress like the Puffy.

Aside from that, the construction of the Puffy and the Puffy Luxe should tick all your boxes at a lesser investment than the Loom & Leaf. Your sleep will thank you and your wallet will too. You might even have enough left over to redo your whole bedroom. Happy decorating!

How important are organic materials? Would you spend more to have organics or is budget a better option for you? Let us know your thoughts in the comments below.

Similar Posts