Puffy vs. Leesa Mattress Comparison 2022 : Which Is Better?

View The Winner

Puffy has gotten a lot of press recently after that appearance on Ellen but is it all show. And Leesa’s tv commercials certainly are heartwarming. Who doesn’t want a cozy bed?

These two are part of the mattress disruption, a wave of companies trying to right the wrong of generations of showroom markups. They’re direct to consumer and can save you quite a bit of money.

Which one should be in your bedroom? Let’s break a few things down in our Puffy versus Leesa review to find your next mattress love.

About The Brands

Puffy Recap Full Review

Why To Like

  • proprietary foam is very cooling
  • offers a lifetime warranty
  • both beds are affordable options

Why To Doubt

  • no option for white glove delivery
  • no showrooms to test out the mattress

Leesa Recap Full Review

Why To Like

  • offers a hybrid mattress option
  • includes the choice of white glove delivery and mattress removal
  • showroom locations in over 100 West Elms

Why To Doubt

  • 10-year warranty is ok but not great
  • more of an investment

Puffy And Leesa Comparison

They do have a few things in common, but they aren’t exactly the same.

How Are Puffy And Leesa Similar?

Let’s start with what they have in common.

Contouring And Support

Remember your grandparents’ mattress? Was it comfortable? Nope. It sounded like rusty springs, and it sagged in the middle.

Old mattresses using inner springs were ok at support for a while, but they quickly lost that support. Even when they didn’t, there wasn’t much contouring. Your shoulders felt like they were up to your ears as you tried to find a comfortable spot. Your arm fell asleep before you did.

If the mattress was “soft,” it sagged in the middle and probably made a lot of noise as it did it. It overextended your spine without easing any of your pressure points.

Both Puffy and Leesa use contouring and support layers to create a mattress that’s comfortable yet supportive. The top layers allow your curves to sink into the mattress while the dense support underneath pushes back. It keeps your spine aligned a lot like it would be if you were upright.

Edge Support

If you try to sit on the edge of the mattress, say early in the morning on a Monday while your coffee brews and you consider calling in sick, some mattresses may not support you. You’ll slide off or feel like you are.

Both mattresses have excellent edge support. They’ve given the mattress structural integrity so that it doesn’t compress towards the sides as you sit or lay near the edge. There’s no sweet spot in the mattress, so couples won’t have to fight about it anymore.

This support gives you the entire mattress for your sleep. If you’re a stomach sleeper, you can use the edge of the bed to get into a comfortable position without feeling like you’re sliding off. You won’t lose precious mattress real estate through compression towards the sides.

Edge support gives memory foam the integrity of a traditional spring mattress.

Motion Transfer

Memory foam is excellent at reducing motion transfer. Motion transfer happens when one partner moves and the other partner feels the mattress jiggling. It’s a bit like a pebble in a pond, and the ripples are what you feel when your partner moves.

Neither mattress transfers motion. Instead, they isolate it, so both partners have a smooth surface to sleep on without the threat of being woken up by someone reenacting the Civil War in their sleep.

ALSO READ:  Casper vs. Purple Mattress Comparison 2022 : Which Is Better?

Motion isolation is also good for reducing the impact of weight differences. Even with a small weight difference between partners, the heavier partner can create an indentation in conventional mattresses that causes them to roll towards each other all night. Motion isolation reduces that to zero, so you only roll towards each other when you want to.

Off-Gassing

Old style memory foam mattresses were famous for their noxious odors. Since memory foam is a petroleum product, they were higher in VOCs than conventional mattresses.

Puffy and Leesa use foams certified by CertiPur-US as having fewer emissions and less VOCs overall. You may notice a slight smell when unboxing your new mattress because of the plastic wrap in the packaging. Allow them both to breathe for a few hours, and you should be fine.

Puffy had slightly less odor, but Puffy is made to order. It spends less time wrapped in plastic, so that may be why the smell was even less than Leesa. If you’re particularly sensitive to odors, you may want to consider an all-natural bed such as Zenhaven or Avocado. Folks without severe allergies should be fine, however.

Manufacturing And Customer Service

Some companies use components shipped in from abroad and built in the US. Others do the opposite.

In this case, both companies use factories and products created in the United States, and their mattresses are assembled here as well. If it’s necessary for you to support a company that manufactures in the US, both of these check that box.

Their customer service is efficient and polite. They seem to be located in the US as well so you shouldn’t have any trouble with language issues or getting your issue resolved. We haven’t had any problems when contacting the company. They are pleasant and understanding.

Accessories

Both companies offer a range of accessories designed to complement your sleep. You can get pillows and foundations with both. You can also get sheets and other accessories from Leesa’s company. You have the option of adding them to your mattress order or investing later.

With Leesa, you could redo your entire sleep situation right down to the foundation if you needed to. It’s nice to one-stop-shop your complete bedroom for sure.

How Are Puffy And Leesa Different?

And now for the good stuff.

Bed Models

Both Puffy and Leesa have a couple of different options for their mattresses.

Puffy

The Puffy original uses just two simple layers to create a cool and comfortable bed. The top layer is their proprietary foam, Cloud Comfort. It conforms to the body faster than traditional memory foam while bouncing back much more quickly. It’s infused with gel so that you never feel warm pockets in the mattress.

The dense support layer is a Core Support layer that pushes back against your body to keep your spine aligned and to give structural integrity to the mattress. It also provides edge support.

The mattress comes in at about a six on a ten point firmness scale. Medium firm support is excellent for combination sleepers and is considered universally comfortable.

The Puffy Luxe uses three different layers for even softer support. The top layer is still Cloud Comfort, but underneath is a pressure relieving comfort foam that conforms to your body while easing it to the support layer.

The same core support layer gives the mattress structural integrity and edge support. It rates at about a five and a half on a ten point scale with the core support layer a seven. It’s ultra soft feeling without losing any support.

Leesa

Leesa’s original mattress is an all foam construction with three layers. The top layer is a breathable comfort layer that conforms to your body while filling in curves and gaps. The layer underneath is a transitional foam that helps relieve pressure and while easing your body to the support layer.

The dense foam layer gives the mattress structural integrity and supports all body types. It pushes back against your body to keep your spine aligned and decompress your lower back. It provides the bed with edge support as well.

ALSO READ:  Casper vs. Saatva Mattress Comparison 2022 : Which Is Better?

It rates at about a seven on a ten point firmness scale.

Leesa’s other option, the Sapira, is a hybrid mattress that uses the same comfort and transitional layers to provide pressure relief and decompression. The support layer is individually wrapped coils that give the mattress structural integrity.

It has more bounce than memory foam, which should please inner spring lovers, but it loses a bit of motion isolation. It rates at about a seven on the ten point firmness scale.

Materials

Both companies use foams, but the construction of the foam is slightly different.

Leesa uses something called Avena foam. It’s open cell and highly breathable, supporting a passive cooling system for the mattress. As you move around, air moves through the open cells, allowing heat to dissipate and moisture to dry. Drying moisture helps the mattress stay cooler while the breathability returns the bed to ambient room temperature quickly.

Puffy’s proprietary foam isn’t exactly memory foam. It’s a contouring Cloud Comfort foam that mimics the responsiveness and bounce of latex. It’s infused with gel before anything dries, so the gel helps to trap heat and moisture the way athletic gear would.

It’s one of the most exciting mattress materials on the market today. Although it isn’t magic, and can only match the ambient temperature of the room you’re in, it does help return the mattress to that temperature ultra-quick. You shouldn’t feel any heat buildup or get any hotspots, a lifesaver for sweaty sleepers or those who are one half of a couple.

Trial Period And Warranty

Puffy gives you 101 nights to try the mattress out before deciding if it’s the right one. You should give your bed at least 30 days to allow it to break in and for your body to adjust.

Leesa gives you one less night for 100 total, but the same advice applies. If you decide that either mattress isn’t the right one, you can contact the company for a return and a refund any time before the trial period is over.

Puffy’s mattresses are guaranteed by a lifetime warranty against mattress defects. You shouldn’t have any abnormal sagging or indentations for the life of the mattress, and the seaming should be durable. If you notice something amiss, contact the company for replacement or repair.

Leesa’s mattresses are covered by a ten-year warranty against the same thing. Make sure for both companies that your mattress is properly supported, and you aren’t using it for anything other than its intended purpose. You might accidentally void the warranty. Also, neither warranty is valid once the mattress leaves the United States or Canada.

Shipping

Puffy’s mattresses are made to order. Once you place your order, the company makes the mattress and compresses it for shipping. Your bed will arrive on your doorstep, ready whenever you are.

Unpack the box and gently tear the plastic from the mattress. If you cut the plastic, you may end up cutting the mattress accidentally. Allow it to inflate for a couple of hours before you sleep on it, and it should be back to the pre-compressed condition in ten to twelve.

Puffy doesn’t have the option of white glove delivery, so plan ahead of time if you need someone to help you set things up or haul your old mattress away.

Leesa offers free shipping for standard delivery. Standard delivery is the same as Puffy. They also offer the option of white glove delivery for a fee of $100. A two-person team will arrive at your house at a predestined time to help you get everything set up. They’ll remove all packaging and make sure your mattress is ready to go.

For an additional $50, they’ll remove your old mattress for recycling or disposal. They can’t remove old bed frames, so you’ll still have to plan for those.

ALSO READ:  Casper vs. Helix Mattress Comparison 2022 : Which Is Better?

Price

Price is slightly different between the two companies and the two different bed models for each. Puffy’s original mattress is less than $1400 for a California king and less than $800 for a twin. The Luxe is a bit more with a California king coming in just under $2000 and the twin just under $1450.

Leesa’s all foam mattress starts at just over $500 for a twin and goes to just under $1200 for a California king. The Sapira is quite a bit more with a twin just under $1000 and the California king just under $1800.

Neither company has any ultra budget options. Both all foam options and the upgrade options are comparable in price with the Leesa edging out Puffy just a bit.

And The Winner Is…

The Puffy Mattress! Buy Online Now

We’re confident recommending Puffy as the best choice based on our analysis of key factors that an average, discerning mattress shopper would care most about.

We’re in love with Puffy’s proprietary foam. It provides excellent contouring that happens immediately and bounces back quickly. There’s no need for the foam to warm up to get the contouring benefits and it moves with you all night long.

The cooling properties of the mattress edge out Leesa’s Avena foam. We think if you struggle to sleep cool, this can be a game changer for you without spending a tone of money for an active cooling base of some sort.

The lifetime warranty makes us feel better about investing in an internet mattress because we know if something goes wrong, Puffy will be there to fix it for us.

  • Quality – Tie
  • Price – Leesa
  • Reputation – Tie
  • Sleep Trial – Puffy
  • Warranty – Puffy
  • Customer Support – Tie
  • Product Selection – Tie

For sleepers with specific needs…

Side Sleepers: Puffy Luxe

Here’s why…

The Puffy Luxe is an excellent mattress for pressure relief. It gives you plenty of contouring for your broadest points while the materials fill in gaps around your waist and lower back.

Stomach Sleepers: The Original Puffy

Here’s why…

Puffy’s original mattress is a medium firm mattress with just two simple layers. The Cloud Comfort foam bounces back quickly and helps keep the spine from overextending.

Back Pain: Puffy Luxe

Here’s why…

The Puffy Luxe has a layer of transitional cooling foam that eases the strain on the lower back and helps it decompress. It also discourages tossing and turning, which can further irritate the back.

Heavy People: Choose Neither

Here’s why…

Heavier weights lose the contouring benefits of the top layers and interact more quickly with the support layers. The foams aren’t created to carry more weight and may experience early sagging and indentations.

We recommend looking to a brand that takes your unique needs into consideration if you’re more than 300 pounds. Winkbeds Plus and Ghostbed are excellent alternatives.

Couples: Choose Puffy Luxe

Here’s why…

The Puffy Luxe provides good combination support while feeling deceptively soft. If you have different sleep preferences, the Luxe could give you both what you want.

If you’re die-hard innerspring fans for couple’s activities, the Sapira is a good option. However, the Cloud Comfort foams of Puffy do respond quickly so you may not mind the foam feeling.

Conclusion

We’re in love with Puffy’s proprietary cooling foams, and we think it lives up to the Ellen Show hype. Although it’s a little more expensive than Leesa’s original mattress, the value lives up to the difference. It’s a refreshing, supportive, and comfortable mattress with plenty of value.

Leesa’s hybrid choice, the Sapira, would be an option for die-hard innerspring fans who want the contouring of foam but don’t want to switch. That would be our only reason to choose Leesa unless your budget is so tight that you’re choosing by price alone. With financing options and a lifetime warranty, we’d still push for Puffy.

Have you tried cooling mattresses before? Tell us all about the results in the comments below.

Similar Posts