Loom & Leaf vs. Casper Mattress Comparison 2023 : Which Is Better?

View The Winner

Saatva and Casper both want to woo you away from the world of showroom mattresses. They both have done a lot to transform the way we buy mattresses online. They’re both innovators and have beds that feel luxe without the added cost of middlemen mattress salespeople.

Now that Saatva has Loom & Leaf, their new budget luxe mattress, Casper might have some competition in that arena.

We’re going to put these two in an all-out competition to see which one deserves your undying love. Let’s take a look.

About the Brands

Before we get started, let’s get a few things straight.

Loom & Leaf Recap Full Review

Why To Like

• hugs like the traditional memory foam mattresses
• affordable
• very supportive for side sleepers
• excellent edge support
• 120-day sleep trial

Why Not To Like

• has no bounce like a traditional innerspring
• no options for heavy sleepers

Casper Recap Full Review

Why To Like

• excellent edge support
• supports a range of sleep positions and firmness preferences
• 100-day sleep trial
• affordable
• very little off-gassing

Why Not To Like

• doesn’t bounce like an innerspring mattress
• no options for heavy sleepers

Loom & Leaf and Casper Comparison

There are a few things the companies have in common with their mattresses, particularly in logistics and in mattress philosophy, but not everything is comparable.

How are Loom & Leaf and Casper Similar?

Let’s take a look at a few things first.

Mattress Philosophy

Conventional mattresses force your body to conform to the surface of the bed. As a result, you wake up in the morning with some weird pains, and it’s difficult to turn your head. Memory foam tried to solve this problem by creating a contouring surface that allows your body to sink in the right points.

However, it created a weird motionless feeling that many people didn’t like and felt it slept hot. Both of these companies have done a lot of work to build a multilayered foam mattress using different adaptive types of foam. On the top layer, the foam is softer and contours to the body to allow your shoulders or hips to sink further into the bed.

On the bottom, there’s a dense foam layer that provides support to the mattress but also keeps your body from sinking too far into the bed. It keeps your spine aligned and relieves pressure.

Although they accomplish this in slightly different ways, it’s the same type of philosophy for comfort and better sleep.

Motion Transfer

Some people are peaceful sleepers, and some people aren’t. Why should the tossers and turners of the world keep the rest of us awake, right?

One of the best parts of memory foam mattresses is their ability to minimize motion transfer between partners. Foam isn’t interconnected like traditional innerspring coils so one partner moving on one end of the bed doesn’t jiggle the whole bed.

Both mattresses do an excellent job of reducing this motion transfer, so you should get some better sleep if this has been a problem for you in the past.

Another benefit of reducing motion transfer is that if one partner is heavier than the other partner, it doesn’t create a central depression in the bed the way a conventional mattress does. Instead, the surface remains relatively flat for both partners, so you aren’t rolling towards each other all night long.

Edge Support

Memory foam isn’t known for holding its shape towards the edges, but these mattresses have pretty good support towards the edges. Saatva worked on their edge support to make sure that you could be comfortable all the way to the side of the mattress and it paid off.

You’ll notice some compression if you sit on the edge of both mattresses, but nothing too major. You might see a little less responsiveness on the Loom & Leaf, but we think it still responds pretty well considering it’s all foam.

Temperature Control

Both companies use a combination of gel inserts, porous foams, and improved airflow to reduce the temperatures at night. Traditional memory foam held heat in the core of the mattress and reflected it back onto your body, but both of these companies have taken steps to reduce that heat. Overall, you should experience a more refreshing night’s sleep with both companies.

Heavier Sleepers

Unfortunately, neither mattress is rated for supporting weights on the heavier end of the spectrum. If the mattress doesn’t consider weight, your body will interact with the support layers of foam much sooner than other sleepers, and you won’t get the contouring feel. There are mattresses on the market that consider higher weights, but unfortunately, these two aren’t going to be a good choice for that.

Warranty

Both companies offer a ten-year warranty that covers defects and replaces your mattress with no shipping cost. It also includes a limited amount of wear and tear that falls outside of the normal process.

Financing

If you can’t swing the cost of the mattress just yet, both companies offer easy financing options that you can choose right at checkout. It helps you get your mattress, and many people are offered excellent terms.

Manufacturing and Customer Service

If you would like to support companies located in the USA, you’ll be glad to know that both companies manufacture their products in the United States and use mostly American made materials in their mattresses.

Getting a claim resolved can be long and frustrating, but both companies appear to have customer service agents located in the United States. Both have excellent reputations for helping customers and getting things done. That should make things a bit easier if you have to deal with customer service.

How are Loom & Leaf and Casper Different?

And now the good stuff. What sets them apart.

Mattress styles

Both companies have focused exclusively on one or two mattress options to make sure they’ve perfected their bed offerings.

Casper Original

The original Casper uses four different layers of foam in contouring and support foam. The top two provide the molded contouring for your body’s pressure points. The bottom layers support the mattress and give you a little bounce back as you interact with the mattress. Right in the middle of the bed is the zoned support that offers softer foam at the shoulders and denser foam around the hip area. It’s rated at a six on the ten-point firmness scale.

The Wave

The Wave uses five layers of foam with a targeted support layer that provides even better lumbar support. If you experience a lot of back issues, the Wave can help get your spine in alignment and decompress those pain points to give you some relief. It molds to your body with the targeted support layer, and it should give you some relief.

The Essential

If you’re on a budget, the Essential offers you a more affordable option. It uses three layers and is intended for those who don’t have any sleep issues and like a general medium firm choice. It’s well under $1000 for all the sizes and might work if you don’t need anything special.

Loom & Leaf

Loom & Leaf has focused on its single mattress option that has two firmness choices. The top layer is a cooling gel that helps your spine decompress and relieve pain. The middle layer is a full five-pound foam that’s manufactured in the United States and provides structure and support for you and the mattress.

The bottom layer is a dense support foam with open-air channels to relieve heat from the core of the mattress. It keeps you a little cooler, but it still hugs you the way classic memory foam does.

The soft version registers at about a six on a ten-point firmness scale. The firmer choice is rated at an eight.

Responsiveness

Both mattresses have an excellent reduction of motion transfer, but the Casper is going to be a bit bouncier overall because of the latex material used in the cover. Latex is more responsive and will give you a bit more pushback.

The Loom & Leaf has virtually no motion response and behaves like the traditional memory foam mattresses you might be more familiar with. It gives you a lot of “hug” and contours just a little bit better than the Casper.

Sleep Trial

Casper gives you 100 nights to try out your mattress to see if it’s the right one for you. It takes some time for the body to adjust to the mattress and for the pain to begin to subside, so the company asks that you sleep on your new bed for at least 30 nights before initiating a return.

The Loom & Leaf offers a 120-night sleep trial, but there are no minimum nights you need to sleep on your new mattress.

You have plenty of time to try either mattress because sleep issues don’t disappear overnight.

Cost

The budget option of the Casper, the essential, is the cheapest option at $700 for a California King. After that, the original Casper is just under $1200 for the same size.

The Loom & Leaf is right in the middle. The California king of both the soft and firm versions sets you back about $1500. After that, the Casper Wave is about $2400 for a California king.

Even though there’s a range of mattresses here, everything is still about half what you would spend at a mattress showroom. The quality of the mattresses is excellent, so as far as value goes, you’re getting a lot for your money.

Delivery

Casper shipping is free, and the mattress arrives on your doorstep in a box. There’s no option for white glove delivery, so if you’re able to set your bed up yourself, it can save you some money.

A traditional delivery service delivers the Loom & Leaf. It costs $99, but you coordinate delivery for when you’re home. The delivery person is there to help you get everything set up, and you can even choose to have your old mattress hauled away. You won’t have to deal with disposing of any of the packaging.

And the Winner Is…

Loom & Leaf Buy Online Now

We’re confident recommending Loom & Leaf as the best choice based on our analysis of key factors that an average, discerning mattress shopper would care most about. We love the Casper and have recommended it before, but in this case, the Loom & Leaf gives you a genuinely luxurious mattress at an affordable cost.

We also love the chance to choose our firmness levels instead of hitting that general middle. The Loom & Leaf also uses materials that are better for the environment and your health, something that usually comes with a premium price tag. Casper has done an excellent job of creating their mattress lines, but Saatva hit all our high points with Loom & Leaf.

• Quality – Loom & Leaf
• Price – Casper
• Reputation – Loom & Leaf
• Sleep Trial – Loom & Leaf
• Warranty – Tie
• Customer Support – Tie
• Product Selection – Tie

For Sleepers with Specific Needs…

Here are a few more targeted recommendations

Side Sleepers: Choose Loom & Leaf

Here’s why. Casper does have the zoned support layers in their mattresses, but the softer version of the Loom & Leaf does an excellent job of molding to a side sleeper’s curves and getting things in the right position. It’s just more comfortable overall.

Stomach Sleepers: Choose Loom & Leaf

Here’s why. The firm Loom & Leaf runs just a hair firmer than the Casper. It gives stomach sleepers the full support they need to keep their spine in alignment and prevent over extending the back.

Back Pain: Choose Loom & Leaf

Here’s why. The firm option of the Loom & Leaf is going to relieve pressure points in the lower back while the traditional memory foam feel is going to discourage tossing and turning, so you aren’t as likely to wrench your back changing positions in the middle of the night.

Heavy People: Choose Neither

Here’s why. Unfortunately, neither mattress is well made for heavier sleepers. If you want the contouring and support to work well, we recommend checking out Winkbeds Plus, a mattress with your specific needs in mind.

Couples: Choose Casper

Here’s why. This is a close one. The responsiveness of the Casper is suitable for couple activities, but it still offers you the motion transfer protection you need when things are done. Also, couples tend to have differences in sleep positions and firmness levels, so we think the all-around features of the Casper might cause fewer fights.

If you can both decide on a particular firmness level, or you both prefer the memory foam feel, the Loom & Leaf would have that edge.

Conclusion

Loom & Leaf gives you a luxury mattress at an affordable price. We love that the materials are more natural and that there’s virtually no off-gassing when the bed is unpackaged. We prefer choosing our firmness levels, and honestly, we love that someone will come to the house to help set things up.

How important are natural materials in a mattress? Would you spend more for that? Let us know in the comments below.