Sleep Guide is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. In addition, we occasionally receive free product in exchange for our honest opinion. Learn more

View The Winner

Two mattress companies with decidedly hipster names, but are they worth the hype? Anyone can combine two things and create the perfect name, but we’re here to see if there’s more to these mattresses than just the name.

In this matchup, we’re looking at two internet mattress companies trying to disrupt the way you buy a mattress. Which one will get you the best night of sleep of your life? Let’s find out.

About the Brands

But first, a few things you should know.

Loom & Leaf Recap Full Review

Why To Like

  • environmentally responsible materials for better health
  • both firm and soft options
  • feels like a luxury mattress for a fraction of the price
  • traditional memory foam “hug.”

Why Not To Like

  • has very little bounce
  • no option for heavy sleepers

Tuft & Needle Recap Full Review

Why To Like

  • the simple concept is less likely to break down
  • good for back pain and spinal support
  • highly affordable
  • unique materials for temperature regulation

Why Not To Like

  • no option for heavy sleepers
  • the mattress might be too firm for side sleepers

Loom & Leaf and Tuft & Needle Comparison

Both companies opt for more straightforward versions of memory foam mattress, but not everything is as similar as it looks. Let’s take a look side by side.

How are Loom & Leaf and Tuft & Needle Similar?

But first, what’s the same.

Contour and Support

Both companies take a straightforward approach to making sure you get the best night of pain-free sleep. With conventional mattresses, it’s difficult to get comfortable because of the way the mattress forces your body to lay in unnatural positions. You end up tossing and turning, building a nest of pillows, and trying to stay asleep all night.

These companies use a combination of support and contour to reduce the amount of time you spend tossing. The top layer is a contoured foam that hugs your body and allows your shoulders and hips to sink in further than your torso and spine. It holds your body there to release pressure.

To keep the mattress from collapsing around you, there’s a denser support foam underneath that gives the mattress structural integrity and prevents the sides from collapsing underneath you when you lay or sit on the edge of the bed.

These layers work together to accomplish opposing tasks. The mattress molds to your body but also gives you full support through your spine and legs.

Motion Transfer

When your partner tosses and turns all night, does it wake you up? Are you mad about it? Don’t be. You can’t do anything about your partner’s sleep habits, but you can reduce how much you feel the tossing and turning.

When conventional mattresses move, you can feel it across the entire bed. When these mattresses move, that motion is isolated to that particular spot, so you get a more peaceful night’s sleep.

Another benefit of reducing motion transfer is that if one partner is heavier than the other, it doesn’t create a dip in the mattress. On a traditional mattress, typically one partner rolls towards the other during the night because of the weight difference. Not here. Both partners get a clean, flat surface to get comfortable.

Temperature Regulation

Memory foam has a reputation for being hot. Both companies have taken a lot of steps to keep you cool during the night.

Tuft & Needle uses charcoal infused fabrics with gel inserts for better contouring and to wick heat away from your body. The foam layers are open cell to improve airflow. Their mattresses do an excellent job of keeping the core of the bed from storing heat.

Loom & Leaf uses natural foams with open cell technology plus cotton coverings to reduce heat differently. Their foams also prevent the core of the mattress from storing heat and reflecting it back to your body so you’ll sleep cooler.

The Tuft & Needle Mint is even cooler than those. It uses a gel infused ice layer to keep you cooler than even their original mattress. It has more gel and more graphite charcoal infused with the materials so even the sweatiest sleepers can get a more refreshing sleep.

Heavier Sleepers

Unfortunately, neither mattress company takes into account higher than average weight. Heavier sleepers may feel that the mattresses aren’t as supportive or feel more firm than the ratings.

More weight means that your body interacts with the support layers more quickly and the contouring layer doesn’t mold to your natural curves the way that it should.

There are mattress companies out there who can better support you and meet your unique needs. Winkbeds Plus, for example, is made explicitly with heavier sleepers in mind.

Financing

It can be difficult sometimes to get the entire amount for a new mattress, so if you aren’t able to swing it just yet, you don’t have to keep sleeping on your old bed. Both companies have financing options that you can select right at the checkout window. You receive an approval decision in a matter of minutes and then proceed with the order as usual.

Warranty

Both companies give you a ten-year warranty to replace mattresses that are defective. They handle the shipping costs and replacement fees. They reserve the right to make judgment calls about wear and tear and the charges associated with that.

Manufacturing and Customer Service

Both companies happily manufacture their mattresses right here in the United States, so you’ll be supporting companies that give back to the local economy.

They also have a reputation for excellent customer service and handling all inquiries promptly. They appear to locate their customer service representatives in the United States as well so there should be no barriers to language or understanding.

How are Loom & Leaf and Tuft & Needle different?

Ok, enough about similarities. Let’s get to the good stuff.

Mattress Styles

Both companies have similar philosophies, but they approach things differently.

Loom & Leaf: Firm or Soft?

Loom & Leaf produces one mattress. They believe that this mattress is the ultimate and have done a lot to perfect it. The mattress has three simple layers intended to cool, contour, and support.

The first layer is a cooling spinal gel that helps the mattress conform strictly to your body and provide cooling relief right away. The next layer is a five-pound foam layer that’s open-celled for breathability and helps your body transition smoothly to the support layer. The bottom layer provides structural support and keeps the sides from collapsing too much when you sit or sleep on the edge.

There are two different firmness options for this mattress. The softer version is about a six on a ten point firmness scale while the firm version is about an eight.

Tuft & Needle: Original or Mint

The original Tuft & Needle uses a straightforward two-layer system of foam. The top layer is a charcoal-infused material with a gel layer that conforms to your body and wicks away heat quickly. The bottom layer is dense support foam. Both layers are proprietary so that they won’t feel exactly like traditional foams.

The Mint is a mattress that’s designed to be even colder than the original. It has three layers of foam with a transition layer that more closely conforms to your curves and helps your body sit in the correct position on the support foam. The base layer improves edge support (something the first struggles with) and helps maintain the structural integrity of the bed.

Edge Support

The Tuft & Needle struggles with edge support. The sides show a lot of compression when you sit on the sides of the mattress or if you use the edge to get comfortable. It’s going to feel like you’re sliding off the edge more than a traditional innerspring mattress would.

Loom & Leaf has excellent edge support with little compression as you sit or lay on the edge. This structure is essential for side sleepers in particular since so many of you use the edge to get into a comfortable position.

Cost

There isn’t an extreme difference in the price of the mattresses, but there’s enough that it could be a consideration. Tuft & Needle’s original mattress is your budget option with a California king coming in at just $700.

The Tuft & Needle Mint is a little more expensive at about $1050 for a California king. Still well under what a typical mattress costs.

The Loom & Leaf is the most expensive. A California king will cost you around $1500 for both the soft and firm versions. Everyone’s mattress is pretty affordable in this round, so unless you’re on a very strict budget, neither option should hurt your wallet too much.

Trial Period

If you’re going to buy an internet mattress, it’s essential to have some reassurance that if you hate it, you aren’t stuck with it. That’s how half these companies even got started.

You need to give your body time to adjust to the mattress before deciding if it’s right for you, and that can take some time. Luckily Tuft & Needle gives you 100 nights to sleep on your mattress. If you decide that you don’t like it, you can initiate a return and get a full refund.

Loom & Leaf gives you 120 nights to try out your new mattress before deciding if it’s right for you. Their customer service is helpful, and they’ll replace the mattress or give you a refund minus shipping.

Shipping

Loom & Leaf offers traditional delivery for mattresses. The five-pound foam layer cannot be compressed without compromising the structural support of the bed. Instead, your bed is delivered to your door during a delivery window. The delivery person is available to set up your mattress, and you can also opt for them to haul your old bed away when you’re checking out.

Tuft & Needle, on the other hand, comes in a compressed box delivered to your front door. You don’t have to be home when it’s delivered, but you won’t have anyone who can help you move it into place or haul your old mattress away.

If you’re able to move your mattress on your own, you can save some money. Tuft & Needle ships for free but Loom & Leaf has a delivery fee of $99.

And The Winner Is…

Loom & Leaf Buy Online Now

Loom & Leaf’s two different firmness options give you more choices for your sleep preferences. It uses eco-friendly materials, and the natural cotton exterior cuts down on the heat. Even though it’s a little more expensive, we think it offers sleepers a little more for the extra price.

  • Quality – Tie
  • Price – Tuft & Needle
  • Reputation – Loom & Leaf (Saatva)
  • Sleep Trial – Loom & Leaf
  • Warranty – Tie
  • Customer Support – Tie
  • Product Selection – Loom & Leaf

For sleepers with specific needs…

And now, a few specific recommendations.

Side Sleepers: Loom & Leaf

Here’s why. Loom & Leaf has two different firmness options, and the softer option should cradle side sleepers more than the other options.

Stomach Sleepers: Choose Loom & Leaf

Here’s why. The firm version of Loom & Leaf should prevent your spine from overextending while you’re sleeping on your stomach. It also has better edge support, so you can use the whole bed to get comfortable.

Back Pain: Loom & Leaf

Here’s why. The firm option offers a lot of support for the lower lumbar region and allows the spine to decompress while remaining in alignment.

Heavy People: Choose Neither

Here’s why. Neither mattress is rated for heavier sleepers. They aren’t going to be supportive and may feel more firm than the rating. You would be better served looking for a mattress rated for your specific needs (such as Winkbeds Plus)

Couples: Choose Loom & Leaf

Here’s why. You have a few more options for how you want to sleep with Loom & Leaf, so unless you’re able to try out the Tuft & Needle’s Mint for hot sleepers, it’s Loom & Leaf should hit your sweet spot.

Conclusion

Loom & Leaf’s mattress is a quality, eco-friendly mattress that feels like a luxury but costs closer to budget. It’s going to be a comfortable option without harming your health or the environment. Plus, it’s beneficial to have someone to help you move the mattress in. Overall, better value at a still friendly price.

Is an eco-friendly mattress critical to your decision? Let us know in the comments below.

Tim

Remember how your parents told you that you were going to sleep your life away? Well that would be perfectly fine with Tim. He's been in search of the most comfortable nights sleep for years and shares his findings with any willing ear.

View all posts

Add comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Sleep Like a Baby

Get tips, tricks and product recommendations to help you sleep through the night.

You're in! As a thank you enjoy $25 Off Our Favorite Pillow.

Pin It on Pinterest