In the pursuit of comfort and healthy restorative sleep there are many claims to the title for “most comfortable mattress,” but few can back up those claims when subjected to a head to head comparison.
In our comparison of the Dreamcloud and Puffy mattresses, we aim to discover which mattress is comfort champ and which is comfort chump.
Winner – Puffy
The Puffy mattress consists of two layers of memory foam and gel-infused memory foam. The gel-infused memory foam is designed to increase airflow by more than 8 x the next leading mattress and enable the mattress to remain cool all night long.
Use Code SAVE750 for $750 Off
Loser – DreamCloud
The Dreamcloud is a well-constructed hybrid mattress with individual layers that combine some of the best features of innerspring, memory foam and latex mattresses. It’s comfortable, sleeps cool and is supportive of the neutral spine.
Use Code SLEEPGUIDE for $250 Off + Extras
Pricing data as of September 2022. Your costs may vary.
In This Article
- Winner – Puffy
- Loser – DreamCloud
- DreamCloud vs. Puffy
- Dreamcloud and Puffy Comparison
- How are Dreamcloud and Puffy Different?
- And The Winner Is…
- For sleepers with specific needs…
- Comparison Results
- More Comparisons
DreamCloud vs. Puffy
DreamCloud Key Takeaways
The secret to the Dreamcloud strategy for defining comfort is in the name. Every mattress produced by Dreamcloud is engineered to give the impression that one is sleeping on a cloud.
Each Dreamcloud mattress includes eight layers of varying materials that combine to provide the highest quality of sleep possible. The eight layers consist of the best features of innerspring, latex and memory foam mattresses including:
- A layer of memory foam infused with cooling gel to dissipate the heat retention common with memory foam material.
- A layer of quilted memory foam adds softness and simulates the “sleeping on a cloud” feeling.
- A layer of natural latex provides bounce and spring to the sleep surface and a high level of firmness., which helps give it a bit of bounce.
- A layer of high-density memory foam included for additional support and contouring.
- The second layer of high-density memory foam to support and enable the spine to remain neutral regardless of sleep position.
- A layer of “pocketed” steel micro-coils that provide deep compression support and dampened motion transfer. The coils also enable increased airflow and a cooler sleep surface.
- The last layer is the base layer which includes another section of high-density memory foam encased in a section of dense foam for increased edge support.
The Dreamcloud brand is one of the more comprehensive mattress brands when it comes to additional perks for the consumer, including white-glove delivery, an extended sleep trial, and an ever-long warranty.
What To Like
What Not To Like
Puffy Key Takeaways
The Puffy mattress brand maintains a reputation for quality comfort and has already claimed the title of “the internet’s most comfortable mattress.” With so many positive reviews and satisfied customers, it’s hard to see how any mattress could challenge that claim.
In addition to two layers of memory foam, a gel-infused memory foam sits sandwich between a six-inch layer of core supportive memory foam that is designed to enable healthy spinal alignment no matter how one chooses to sleep on the bed. Both of the memory foam layers included in the Puffy mattress are encased in a machine washable, zippable cover.
Like Dreamcloud the Puffy mattress includes an extensive sleep trial and a comprehensive warranty that extends for the life of the mattress.
Lofty titles, white-glove delivery, extended warranties, and sleep trials are all terrific perks, but a mattress brand cannot claim to be the winner of our comparison without first offering an exceptionally comfortable and supportive mattress.
What To Like
What Not To Like
Dreamcloud and Puffy Comparison
How are Dreamcloud and Puffy Similar?
There are many similarities between the Dreamcloud and Puffy mattresses, the most obvious being the number of satisfied customers who have reviewed that mattress online. Consumers cannot stop raving about either mattress.
Reviews for the Dreamcloud mattress are constantly positive with few complaints that amount to little more than a preference for a softer mattress. The Puffy mattress however not only well reviewed, but it’s also famous having been featured on an episode of Ellen DeGeneres.
The second most obvious similarity between the two brands is the quality of their design and construction.
Both mattresses are constructed from high-quality materials and, in general, feel as though one is sleeping on a mattress that is well constructed, highly supportive and designed to be universally comfortable.
Both the Dreamcloud and Puffy mattresses include varying layers of memory foam and gel-infused memory foam.
When combined these features enable both mattresses to provide a cool sleep surface that cradles the body just enough to feel comfortable without sinking into the mattress.
The Dreamcloud and Puffy mattresses are also similarly priced. The cost of a queen size mattress for both brands falls between approximately $1,400 and $1,600.
Both the Dreamcloud and Puffy brands also maintain a reputation for quality, customer service, and overall customer satisfaction. Their positive reputation is due, in no doubt, to the inclusion of several valuable incentives such as:
- Lifetime warranty
- Free delivery
- Extended sleep trials
- Helpful customer service & support
The Dreamcloud and Puffy mattresses are also similar in their limited selection. Neither mattress is offered in different firmness levels or any variation other than the size of the mattress.
The firmness level for both mattresses also falls into the “medium firm” category ranging between 5 and 6.5 on a scale of 10, with 10 representing the “very firm.”
Unfortunately, both mattresses are only available for purchase from their respective online stores. Neither brand is available for purchase on Amazon nor do they operate a brick & mortar location or authorizes the sale of their product by mattress wholesalers.
How are Dreamcloud and Puffy Different?
The similarities between the Dreamcloud and Puffy mattresses end with a closer examination of the two mattresses. Though both mattresses include memory foam in their design and construction, the method in which those memory foams are employed varies drastically.
The Dreamcloud mattress features a hybrid design wherein eight specific layers combine to provide cool, comforting support. The Puffy mattress, however, only employs two layers which rival the Dreamcloud’s eight in terms of comfort and support provided to the sleeper.
Concerning durability, the Dreamcloud mattress outpaces the Puffy mattress due to the inclusion of higher density foams than those used in the Puffy mattress.
However, it is for the same reason that the Puffy mattress scores higher in motion isolation, as the lower density foams do a better job and absorbing and dampening movement.
The lower density foams in the Puffy mattress also enable the mattress to be more conforming than the Dreamcloud mattress, which may or may not be seen as a positive feature depending on one’s preference for a softer, or firmer mattress.
The Dreamcloud and Puffy mattresses differ drastically on the level of edge support that they provide. The Dreamcloud mattress performs poorly when compared to the Puffy mattress with sleepers reporting a significant degree of “roll-off” when sleeping, and compression when getting in and out of bed.
Both mattresses can be considered well suited for couples but for different reasons. The Dreamcloud mattress is firmer than the Puffy mattress, which gives it more spring and makes it better suited for sex.
However, due to the springy nature of the mattress, the Dreamcloud has a high degree of motion transfer when compared to the Puffy, which means that sleepers run a higher couples risk waking their sleep partner when moving.
The two mattresses also offer significantly different levels of deep compression support. The Puffy mattress includes a layer of supportive core memory foam; however, it does not provide anywhere near the amount of deep compression support that is offered by the Deamcloud mattress.
The Dreamcloud mattress, on the other hand, includes a layer of pocketed inner coils that provide a high level of deep compression support, even when slept on by individuals who weigh more than 230 pounds.
And The Winner Is…
The Puffy Mattress Buy Online Now
We’re confident in recommending Puffy as the best choice based on our analysis of key factors that an average, discerning mattress shopper would care most about.
The Dreamcloud mattress scores high in customer satisfaction, but it is consistently edged out by the Puffy mattress in almost every category, although admittedly not by much.
The Puffy mattress lives up to its title of “the internet’s most comfortable mattress” because it provides the most comfort possible for the widest range of people.
The Puffy mattress is designed to be conforming, yet supportive. These features are beneficial to side, stomach and back sleepers, and those who suffer from back pain, which according to report conducted by the George Institute for International Health, accounts for 80% of adults.
However, many of the Puffy mattresses features that can be considered a negative are actually a manner of personal preference. We like the Puffy mattress precisely because it appeals to such a large array of sleep types as a medium-firm, conforming, temperature neutral mattress.
Where the Puffy mattress truly excels is pressure relief. The conforming nature of the mattress enables the memory foam to relieve pressure points and cradle the spine. Thus improving spinal alignment and facilitating a more restorative night of sleep.
The conforming support is also beneficial to the neck and hips which are prevented from sinking uncomfortably into the mattress and exerting excess strain on the bodies most sensitive areas.
The Puffy mattress is also more adept at meeting the sleep needs of couples. The Puffy mattress dampens motion to a high degree and provides more edge support than the Dreamcloud which means less disturbance felt across the entire bed, even when getting in and out.
Additionally, as “the internet’s most comfortable mattress” it is very common for retailers to offer the Puffy mattress at a discounted rate should it be purchased online.
The Dreamcloud mattress offers a longer sleep trial than the Puffy mattress, but one will hardly need more time than the 101 days provided by Puffy to decide if it is the right mattress.
- Quality – Puffy
- Price – Puffy
- Reputation – Puffy
- Sleep Trial – Dreamcloud
- Warranty – Tie
- Customer Support – Dreamcloud
- Product Selection – Tie
For sleepers with specific needs…
Side Sleepers: The Puffy Mattress
Sleeping on one’s side allows for a large gap to form between the head and the surface of the mattress.
The Puffy mattress is more likely to perform well for side sleepers than the Dreamcloud mattress because it is more conforming and allows the body to sink deeper into the mattress, thus reducing how far the neck and head must travel before resting on the sleep surface.
Stomach Sleepers: The Dreamcloud Mattress
Sleeping on one’s stomach often allows the hips to sink into the mattress, and the head and neck to be strained upward. This positioning leads to poor spinal alignment and uneven pressure to be exerted on the sensitive areas of the body.
The Dreamcloud mattresses eight layers of high-grade memory foam, gel-infused memory foam, and the pocketed inner coil support core ensure that sleepers not only feel comfortable but remain cool all night long and never allow the body to sink too far into the mattress causing discomfort.
Thus, the Dreamcloud mattress is the better mattress for side sleepers because it is firmer and less conforming than the Puffy mattress.
Back Pain: The Puffy Mattress
The Puffy mattress is ideally suited to relieving back pain and supporting back sleepers. The Puffy mattress cradles the body allowing the spine to assume a natural alignment while remaining supported in areas like the lumbar and the shoulders.
In contrast, the Dreamcloud mattress is firmer than the Puffy mattress which makes it ideal for stomach sleepers but may not provide enough conforming support for those who suffer from chronic back pain.
Furthermore, the Puffy mattress is reported as more comfortable across a range of sleep types which means that individuals can find relief from chronic back pain regardless of the way in which they sleep.
Heavy People: The Dreamcloud Mattress
The Dreamcloud mattress performs better for heavier individuals, specifically those who weigh more than 230 pounds.
The Dreamcloud mattress features eight layers, including a combination of memory foam and pocketed innerspring support, when combined these layers provide a higher level of deep compression support.
The Puffy mattress is less firm and consists of lower density foams which, though comfortable, may allow heavier individuals to sink too far into the mattress and cause uneven pressure, strain, and poor spinal alignment.
Couples: The Puffy Mattress
The Puffy mattress is more likely than the Dreamcloud mattress to perform well for couples because of its superior edge support and motion isolation. Though the Dreamcloud provides a springy feel that is beneficial to sex, the Puffy mattress provides a more beneficial overall sleep surface for couples.
The memory foam construction of the Puffy mattress enables it to better isolated and dampen motion which means couples are less likely to disturb one another when moving about the mattress.
Furthermore, the Puffy mattress features a reinforced edge which provides a high level of edge support and makes it easier to get in and out of bed with the least amount of disturbance to ones sleep, partner.
It should be noted that our comparison of the Dreamcloud and Puffy mattresses was a close competition. Both mattresses brands successful upheld their reputations for quality and comfort. Each mattress features an innovative design and includes a comprehensive lifetime warranty and free delivery.
However, it is the slight ways in which the Dreamcloud and Puffy mattresses are different that prove the Puffy mattress to be the overall better choice.
The DreamCloud mattress does not provide the levels of conforming, supportive comfort provided by the Puffy mattress. The Puffy mattress excels at providing the most comfort for the widest range of individuals.
In fact, the Puffy mattress is so widely compatible that it is consistently voted “the internet’s most comfortable mattress” and has even been featured in an episode of Ellen, where it earned her celebrity endorsement.
Though we wouldn’t recommend basing all of your purchasing decisions on the endorsement of a celebrity, in the case of the Puffy mattress the endorsement is one more positive review in the retinue of thousands of satisfied customers.