Sleep Guide is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. In addition, we occasionally receive free product in exchange for our honest opinion. Learn more

View The Winner

Stepping into the bedroom today, we have two heavy hitters ready to duke it out for which one of these factory-direct mattresses can give you a better night’s sleep. Casper, the fan favorite, will be taking on the working-class challenger, Tuft & Needle.

There are so many mattress brands out there nowadays that it has gotten difficult to decide in which mattress model and brand is the right one to invest. Sleep is important. One might say that quality sleep is crucial to leading a high quality of life. So, we are going to break down these two mattresses to find out which one is better.

About These Two Brands

Casper Recap Full Review

What To Like

  • The Zoned Support Transition layer.
  • Superior edge support for an all-foam mattress.
  • Compatible with adjustable base and has other accessories.

What Not To Like

  • The company may be growing too fast. Some customer support issues reported.
  • Consumer reports have shown some durability issues.

Casper is taking the bed-in-a-box industry by storm with their self-entitled model, The Casper. It is an all-foam mattress with a two-tone polyester cover that will be delivered directly to your door in a compressed box. It is marketed towards combination sleepers, which means it will work well, for stomach, back, or side-sleepers as well.

Most Casper reviews rate the firmness on a scale of  7 out of 10. This puts it just this mattress smack-dab in the middle of medium and medium-firm. The Casper boasts four layers of foam and is 10 inches thick.

Considerations

  • The Casper offers a 100-night trial period with a full refund and free pickup.
  • Casper offers a 10-year limited warranty.
  • Free Shipping to the contiguous United States and Canada.
  • CertiPUR-US® Certified – Casper mattresses were tested and met these rigorous environmental standards.
  • Made in the United States.

Tuft & Needle Recap Full Review

Why to Like

  • The Price. At $575 for a Queen, it’s nearly unbeatable.
  • Tuft & Needle is environmentally conscientious,
  • Simplified shopping experience.
  • Gimmick-free.

Why to Doubt

  • Might not be right for those looking for classic foam feel.
  • Not as heavy-person friendly as some beds.

Tuft & Needle has recently made some design changes since their initial attempt to disrupt the mattress market in 2012. The founders, who are two former Silicon Valley engineers, wanted to make a mattress that would work wonderfully for any sleeper. To do that, they had to break down and simplify the components of what makes a great mattress great.

Through their research, they found that most essential aspects of producing a quality mattress could be broken down into pressure relief, support, and cooling. The development of Tuft & Needle’s proprietary foam was the result of this narrowed focus. And the 2018 updates have taken the T&N product to the next level. The 10-inch thick mattress is comprised of just two layers.

Considerations

  • Tuft & Needle offers a 100-night trial period with a 100% refund and free removal if you do not wish to keep the mattress.
  • 10-year non-prorated warranty.
  • CertiPUR-US® Certified – Casper mattresses were tested and met the exhaustive conditions for environmental standards.
  • GREENGUARD Certified – Tuft & Needle promotes healthy indoor environment by being made with low emissions.
  • OEKO-TEX® Certified –  Tuft & Needle mattresses are free of over 300 toxic chemicals.
  • Made in the USA.

Tuft & Needle and Casper Comparison

So, you have seen the basic overview of each brand, but how do they compare against one another? In this section, we’ll dissect a couple of key similarities and differences.

How are Casper and Tuft & Needle Similar

Warranty

Both Casper and Tuft & Needle offer a 10-year limited warranty.

Sleep Trial

Both brands offer a 100-night sleep trial with full refund available to those who are not 100 percent satisfied with the product. Neither company deducts any of your refund for a ‘pickup charge’.

Shipping

Both offer free shipping inside of the United States and Canada. Although they both ship free to the US mainland, Casper and Tuft & Needle each have shipping fees to Alaska and Hawaii.

The Cover

Though slightly different, when it comes down to overall functionality, the covers are quite comparable. The T&N cover is a tad thinner, so it may be a just a hair cooler. However, many people like the aesthetics of the Casper cover better because the T&N cover is so thin that it is see-through.

Overall Quality

With all things considered the overall quality of the product is comparable. Both of these beds sleep cool. And both offer support and allow for reduced tension in the right areas. In many ways, it comes down to personal preference, do you want to float on top of the bed, like with the T&N or do you want to be hugged by the bed like with the Casper.

Firmness

Although Tuft & Needle is just a hair softer than The Casper, they are both in the medium range and quite similar. Tuft & Needle reviews and lab tests put the firmness at around 6.5 to 7. This rating makes it a little softer than the Casper and closer to exact medium firmness. As for the Casper reviews, most rate the firmness on a scale of  7 out of 10. This puts it just this mattress smack-dab in the middle of medium and medium-firm.

How are Casper and Tuft & Needle Different

Price

The Casper is by no means expensive when compared to other foam mattress brands. It comes in at $895 for a Full, $995, for a Queen and $1195 for a King-size. But Tuft & Needle is a bargain at $475 for a Full, $575 for a Queen, and just $700 for a King-size. They stay true to their motto, “An Exceptional Mattress at a Fair Price.”

T&N have cut through the mattress industry gimmicks and produced a quality product without all of the markups. T&N’s price to quality ratio is unbeatable.

Construction

Tuft & Needle uses just two layers of foam. The comfort layer is 3 inches thick and is the proprietary ‘adaptive’ foam designed by Daehee Park and John-Thomas Marino, T&N’s founders and engineers.

This adaptive foam gives fantastic pressure relief that is similar to latex and memory foams, but it is infused with a cooling gel and uses graphite to help transfer heat away from the body, allowing the sleeping surface to remain cool.

The Base Layer is the 7 inches of high-density polyfoam that makes up the bed’s foundation and gives it its shape.

The Casper uses four layers of foam. The open-cell comfort foam layer that keeps the sleeping surface breathable and cool. It also gives a little bit of bounce to the top.

The responsive, contour layer is made up of high-density memory foam. This is the part of the mattress that helps to relieve pressure and isolate motion. It also helps to trap and keep excess heat away from the body.

The transition layer is Casper’s trademarked Zoned Support layer. The Zoned Support™ is designed to keep your spine aligned by altering support levels along the length of the bed.

The last piece of foam is the dense support layer. This final section acts as the foundation and acts to support the other three layers of foam.

How they Feel

Both mattresses have a little more bounce than traditional foam beds. The T&N mattress does have a little bit of sink, but because of the proprietary design of the adaptive foam, it has a lot less sinkage and less body hug than other foam mattresses. You get a floating feeling while laying on top of this surface.

The cover material is a soft polyester-Tactel nylon blend. It is ultra-thin which makes the Tuft & Needle very breathable. The light cover coupled with the fact that you that the foam does not hug your body makes it one of the best cooling sleeping surfaces available.

The Casper has surprisingly little sinkage compared to other memory-foam mattresses as well, but it still has quite a bit of hug. The latex-like comfort layer does give the Casper a little bit of bounce, and when you couple these to aspects together, it gives a snug feel like you are sleeping contoured on top of the bed, but not inside of it.

The polyester cover is thin and breathable, and there is a lovely balance between the comfort layer and contour layer, which gives the surface an even feel with your weight well distributed.

Motion Transfer

The T&N ADAPTIVE® Foam is sufficiently better at stopping the transfer of motion across the surface of the bed. While The Casper hangs in admirably around the industry averages, the Tuft & Needle does much better than average and shows considerably less motion picked up by seismic sensors.

Environmental Awareness

For those who are environmentally conscientious, Tuft & Needle breaks the mold with their product standards. You would be hard-pressed to find another mattress manufacturer in their price-range that is CertiPUR-US®, GREENGUARD certified, and OEKO-TEX® certified. They genuinely consider the protecting environment a priority.

Tuft & Needle seems to hold themselves to a higher standard when it comes to protecting the environment and their clients’ health. This is something that though not important to everyone, is becoming more and more important to the masses.

And The Winner is …

The Tuft & Needle Mattress Buy Online Now

We’re confident recommending Tuft & Needle as the best choice based on our analysis of key factors that an average, discerning mattress shopper would care most about. Both mattress companies offer a great product, but Tuft & Needle is the clear winner. After analyzing both brands, T&N exceed the standards that most people are looking for. And when we consider the fact that their product comes in at nearly half the price of The Casper, it becomes a no-brainer.

If I purchased the Casper, then found out about the Tuft & Needle mattress and all it has to offer and then realized that I paid nearly double for the Casper, I would feel cheated. With the T&N you can go to sleep each night and rest your head with the knowledge that you got the best deal on a high-end foam mattress.

**Table Content**

  • Quality – Tie
  • Price – Tuft & Needle
  • Reputation – Tie
  • Sleep Trial – Tie
  • Warranty – Tie
  • Customer Support – Tuft & Needle
  • Product Selection – Casper

For Sleepers with Specific Needs

Side Sleepers: Choose Tuft & Needle

Side sleepers prefer the Tuft & Needle mattress because of the pressure relief that is given by the T&N ADAPTIVE® foam. And despite what mattress store salesmen claim, the best mattress for side sleepers is what they actually find comfortable. And this mattress is extremely comfortable for most side sleepers.

Stomach Sleepers: Choose Tuft & Needle

Stomach sleepers love this mattress because it supports the chest to allow for natural breathing without arching your back into an uncomfortable position. It keeps your hips up and your weight distributed.

People With Back Pain: Choose Tuft & Needle

Chronic back pains are often alleviated by this mattress because pressure on key points such as the shoulders and hips is reduced. This allows the back to align in a more natural manner and allows for a bit of spinal decompression.

Heavy People: Choose Tuft & Needle

Heavier and Taller people tend to prefer Tuft & Needle because of the highly responsive proprietary comfort layer. It responds well and conforms to weight without the more prominent pressure areas such as the hips sinking in too deeply.

Couples: Choose Tuft & Needle

Couples prefer this mattress because of its astoundingly limited transfer of motion. Active sleepers won’t disturb their partner’s sleep. Many couples have slightly different sleep schedules and have to get in and out of bed at different times. The Tuft & Needle mattress absorbs the energy when someone climbs in and out of bed, allowing the sleeper to stay soundly sleeping.

Conclusion

Tuft & Needle is a budget-friendly, streamlined mattress that performs as well as its competitors that cost four times its price. Choosing to give the Tuft & Needle mattress a try is risk-free, as there are a 100-night, money-back trial, and a 10-year warranty.

If you are interested in a high-tech mattress, you may want to have a look at Purple’s product line.

Tim

Remember how your parents told you that you were going to sleep your life away? Well that would be perfectly fine with Tim. He's been in search of the most comfortable nights sleep for years and shares his findings with any willing ear.

View all posts

Add comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Sleep Like a Baby

Get tips, tricks and product recommendations to help you sleep through the night.

You're in! As a thank you enjoy $25 Off Our Favorite Pillow.

Pin It on Pinterest