Sleep Guide is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. In addition, we occasionally receive free product in exchange for our honest opinion. Learn more

View The Winner

A giant in the industry and an upstart internet company. Both offer memory foam, and both have helped, in their own way, to transform the world of mattresses. Many consider the Tempur-Pedic line to be the end-all of memory foam, but Casper is hoping to change that perception.

So, which is it? The master or the apprentice? We’ve put together an in-depth comparison of Casper versus Tempur-Pedic and our honest opinion about which one should be your final choice. Let’s take a look.

About the Brands

Casper Recap Full Review

What To Like

  • Cools better than most of the competition
  • Strong combination support
  • Free shipping and returns to go with 100-day trial period
  • Outstanding edge support
  • Certified by Centri-Pur

What Not To Like

  • Limited bounce and lack of innerspring feel
  • Less kind to heavier sleepers
  • Three styles available, which is less than some competitors’ offerings

Tempur-Pedic Recap Full Review

What To Like

  • Wide range of available models
  • Well-established brand
  • Try before you buy
  • Hybrid offerings

What Not To Like

  • Price – on the expensive side
  • Most models sleep hot
  • Fairly high off-gassing odor

Casper and Tempur-Pedic Comparison

Now it’s time to jump into our more in-depth comparison.

How are Casper and Tempur-Pedic similar?

It’s difficult to discuss in depth the similarities because there’s such a wide range of Tempur-Pedic mattresses. In some fundamental ways, however, there are a few similarities.

Foam Type

Both Casper and the Tempur-Pedic line uses the concept of contour/support to provide pressure relief and better positioning. Contouring layers are softer so that your hips and shoulders sink into the mattress rather than conforming to the mattress. Underneath the support layer is denser and keeps your spine in better alignment.

Even Tempur-Pedic’s flex models use this concept with the coils acting as the denser support layer. They’re often sandwiched in foam to provide flexibility and reduce motion transfer but provide the firm support customarily given by the base foam layers.

Temperature

Both companies have put a lot of time and effort into making their mattresses cooler. If you remember the early days of memory foam, you might be under the impression that it’s a hot, sinking mess. They’ve come a long way.

Both use layers of open cell foam to improve airflow between the layers and prevent heat from getting trapped in the core. If the center stays cool, it won’t reflect back on your body as you sleep. Even if you sink further into the foam, you shouldn’t feel an increase in heat overall.

However, the heaviest and/or warmest sleepers might still experience some heat transfer from the sink in the foam. Be advised that in this case, other options might suit you better.

Warranty

They both have 10-year warranties that repair or replace defective mattresses. Each company reserves the right to decide if repair or replacement is needed and shipping and handling costs may be included depending on the situation.

Mattress Sizes

Both companies offer a range of sizes for each type of mattress. There are a few Tempur-Pedic models not available in twin or twin xl, but by far each model for both companies comes in twin through California King.

Manufacturing and Customer Service

Customer service is typically the one place where a company loses a previously dedicated customer. Both companies appear to have customer service agents located in the United States and both are usually rated as being very satisfactory. Neither company discloses officially where they source their customer service agents.

Manufacturing seems to be mostly in the US for both companies as well with components coming from international markets.

How are Casper and Tempur-Pedic different?

There are quite a few fundamental differences in the way these two companies approach things.

Mattress styles

First, their mattress style offerings differ quite a bit.

Casper

Casper comes in three different types of mattresses. The Casper is the original mattress with four layers of contouring/supporting foam and medium firmness. It offers excellent support for side sleepers and those with back issues while providing good combination support for partners who may not have the same patterns or problems.

The Wave is a five-layer foam mattress with more targeted support for lower lumbar pain. It uses ergonomic, targeted support along with the zoned support layer for better positioning and less tossing and turning.

The Essential is Casper’s budget line with three layers of support. It provides structural support but is targeted towards sleepers who have no unique sleep needs and like a medium firmness in their mattress. Its main draw is the incredibly affordable price point with all mattress sizes coming in at well under $1000.

Tempur-Pedic

Tempur-Pedic is a bit more complicated. Their range is extensive at this point and comes in a variety of models within a specific line divided by foam and hybrid as well as along the firmness scale.

Cloud models are soft, all foam mattresses. They feature both contouring and support foam, but they range much softer on the ten point scale, some as low as a four. They have a smart climate system to reduce heat from the sink of the ultrasoft model.

Contour is firmer and intended for those who have back pain or pain from other pressure points. It also features the climate control layer to reduce heat, a welcome addition to those who remember the original Tempur-Pedic mattress.

The Flex line is the hybrid mattress line. It uses both foam for contouring and a layer of individually wrapped coils, so it has more bounce and a traditional innerspring feel. It still uses cooling materials to reduce heat, and the coils are sandwiched and individually wrapped to reduce the motion transfer associated with conventional mattresses.

They also have a luxury mattress known as the Grandbed that features two contouring layers and two support layers of foam. The top material is a silk-cashmere blend material, and it features diamond embossing across the side material. It is by far the most expensive mattress in their line and is 15 inches deep. It starts at size Queen.

Bounce

Tempur-Pedic’s mattresses except for the Flex line all have that slow sink and pretty serious reduction in motion transfer. While lovers of memory foam might love this, it can be difficult to adjust as a couple for sex or just general responsiveness.

Casper uses a comfort foam on top to help increase bounceback while retaining the feel of memory foam. Tempur-Pedic’s Flex line produces this response because of the coil structure. If you’re trying to get away from innerspring designs, keep in mind that Tempur-Pedic foam is going to come closer to that “dead foam” feel than the Casper.

Trial period

Tempur-Pedic adheres to the original concept of the sleep trial with 90 days. Casper gives you an extra ten days to figure out if you’re thrilled. Both companies ask that you sleep on the mattress for at least 30 days before initiating a return.

Price

The investment is the most glaring difference between Casper and Tempur-Pedic. Even the most expensive mattress at Casper barely touches the cost of Tempur-Pedic. The average price of a Casper hovers around $1000 or below.

Tempur-Pedic averages are closer to $2000 or under, but the top of the line mattresses can cost as much as $7000 or more. It’s a serious investment if you’re determined to go with a highly established mattress company.

Showrooms

Casper mattresses are difficult to try out in person. They have one showroom located in Toronto, and you can also try out some models of the bed in some West Elm stores. If you can’t get to either of those places, you’ve got to trust that they’ll get your mattress right.

Tempur-Pedic, on the other hand, is in plenty of showrooms, mattress stores, and big-box stores across the United States and Canada. It’s much easier to try out all the models of the Tempur-Pedic before you buy to help you make a decision.

Reputation

Tempur-Pedic is the most famous memory foam mattress line out there. They’ve been in business for well over 20 years and have had plenty of time to perfect each of their lines. You can find them in plenty of big name mattress stores, and with an extensive website designed to help you narrow down your choices, you’ve got plenty of chances to interact before you buy.

The perception of the company is overwhelmingly positive from products to customer service. If you want a big name to back up your mattress, Tempur-Pedic is as big as they come.

Casper has been in business far less time, less than ten years. They have few showroom opportunities and are in no big mattress stores. They haven’t had the time to prove mattress durability, but customers seem very satisfied overall with the mattress and customer service.

They began the company to cut out all those mattress middlemen. The choice to move away from mattress companies and distributors means you get a much cheaper, yet quality mattress. The company’s reviews are pretty steady from year to year as a result.

And The Winner Is…

The Casper Mattress Buy Online Now

And here’s why. We’re confident recommending Casper as the best choice based on our analysis of key factors that an average, discerning mattress shopper would care most about.

The Tempur-Pedic is a well-established brand with a lot more options than the Casper, but the investment for a Tempur-Pedic is just breathtaking. Casper cuts out the middleman to offer a mattress that’s well within reach but doesn’t compromise on quality. Tempur-Pedic still uses this old model, and the pricing structure reflects this.

Casper focuses on a handful of mattresses and does them well. For the majority of sleepers, the price difference isn’t worth it.

Some of Tempur-Pedic’s mattresses might edge Casper out for specific sleep issues, but the vast majority does not warrant the massive price increase. Spending money on your health is an excellent idea and you should never sacrifice your well-being for the sake of a price tag. However, we don’t feel the extra expense is warranted here. That’s our final word.

  • Quality – Casper
  • Price – Casper
  • Reputation – Tempur-Pedic
  • Sleep Trial – Casper
  • Warranty – Tie
  • Customer Support – Casper
  • Product Selection – Tempur-Pedic

For Sleepers with Specific Needs

For those who have more specific needs at night, we haven’t forgotten you.

Side Sleepers: Choose Casper

Here’s why. Casper’s mattresses have good side support and a zoned support layer to help side sleepers prevent overextension of the torso and painful pressure points at the shoulders and the hips.

Stomach Sleepers: Choose Casper

Here’s why. Casper’s medium firmness helps keep the spine and shoulders in alignment. The edge support is good enough to prevent weird sleeping positions that will cause pain later.

Back Pain: Choose Casper

Here’s why. Yes, Tempur-Pedic has options for back pain, but at nearly $1000 more, why? Casper’s Wave is particularly suited to those with pain in the lower lumbar region, and it helps prevent tossing and turning which can make back problems worse.

Heavy People: Choose Tempur-Pedic

Here’s why. Casper just isn’t meant for those on the heavier spectrum. Tempur-Pedic’s Contour line will give more support and prevent some of the sinkage sleepers will feel with Casper. That said, neither mattress is specially made for heavy sleepers. Look to Winkbeds for that option. They offer a mattress that considers the weight of those on the heavier end of the spectrum and also have a climate control foundation to provide further cooling relief.

Couples: Choose Casper

Here’s why. Casper’s combination support should satisfy couples with different sleep preferences and still offer some bounce for sex. If you really must have the innerspring feel, your option is the Tempur-Pedic Flex, and excellent, but seriously expensive, alternative.

Conclusion:

We feel that even in certain situations where Tempur-Pedic might have a slight edge in construction or more firmness choices, by far the best value for the money is going to be Casper. They’ve concentrated on three types of mattresses and have done them well. While spending money for your health is the best thing you can do, we aren’t convinced the extra is worth it in this case. The vast majority of you are going find a lot of satisfaction with the Casper mattress line.

Is the price difference between Casper and Tempur-Pedic worth it? Let us know what you think in the comments below.

Tim

Remember how your parents told you that you were going to sleep your life away? Well that would be perfectly fine with Tim. He's been in search of the most comfortable nights sleep for years and shares his findings with any willing ear.

View all posts

Add comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Sleep Like a Baby

Get tips, tricks and product recommendations to help you sleep through the night.

You're in! As a thank you enjoy $25 Off Our Favorite Pillow.

Pin It on Pinterest