Sleep Guide is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. In addition, we occasionally receive free product in exchange for our honest opinion. Learn more

View The Winner

In this review, two online mattress heavyweights go head to head to see which the champion of your bedroom will be. Stepping in from Westport, Connecticut we have Saatva, a high-quality innerspring bed. And the Challenger is Casper. A latex and polyurethane foam bed in a box hailing from New York City.

Both beds have changed the face of mattress buying as we know it, but we are trying to determine which bed is best suited for any type of sleeper. And only one will be left standing at the end of this review.

To keep things fair in firmness, we’ll be looking at the Saatva’s Luxury Firm mattress and Casper Sleeps, The Casper.

About These Two Brands

Saatva Recap Full Review

What To Like

  • Has excellent edge support.
  • Durability. This mattress is built to last.
  • High-quality materials and workmanship.
  • Back Sleepers Give High Ratings.

What Not To Like

  • Motion transfer is more prevalent.
  • Not as friendly for heavier side sleepers.

The Saatva Company is an online-only retailer that got its start back in 2010. Eight years may not seem like a long time, but compared to young up-and-comers like Casper Sleep, Saatva is like the veteran pro. Saatva also makes memory foam mattresses under the name, Loom and Leaf and latex sleep products under the name Zenhaven.

Saatva’s Luxury Firm model is available in a Premier Luxury Version, which is 14.5 inches thick, and the Custom Slim version which is just 11.5 inches thick. They are designed to have the same feel and firmness, but it should be noted that the 14.5-inch version is not compatible with the Saatva adjustable base.

Saatva added new design twists to traditional innerspring mattresses. They utilize individually wrapped coils that are housed underneath a euro-style pillow top and a light layer of memory foam. Below the individual coils, is a layer of foam that transitions to the more traditional steel coils.

The quilted cover is 100 percent organic cotton and is soft and breathable. Saatva added some extra foam and tightened the quilting in the lumbar area to create additional lower-back support.

Considerations

  • Saatva offers a 120-night sleep trial. There is a 99 dollar transportation fee if you decide to return the mattress.
  • Saatva comes with a 15-year limited warranty.
  • Free White Glove Delivery (they’ll set up your bed for you)
  • CertiPUR-US® Certified – Purple mattresses were tested and met the exhaustive conditions for environmental standards.
  • Innersprings are recycled steel.
  • Made in the USA.

Casper Recap Full Review

What To Like

  • Great Full Body Support.
  • Side Sleeper Friendly.
  • Local retailers so you can test the bed.
  • Free pickup for those opt-out during sleep trial.

What Not To Like

  • Recent complaints about customer service.
  • Previous iterations have had complaints about durability.

Casper is probably the biggest name in the bed in a box industry right now. They recently struck a deal with Target to offer retail locations, and the deal pushed them beyond the $500 million valuation mark. At just 4-years-old, Casper is taking the sleep industry by storm.

Casper Sleep’s best-selling model, The Casper has been through a few different iterations. In 2018 they revamped the transition layer to improve support. Like most ‘bed in a box’ mattresses, it comes delivered directly to your door in a compressed box.

The Casper is an All-Foam mattress that stands 10 inches tall. The queen-size weighs in at 71 pounds. Construction of this bed consists of four different foam layers for head-to-toe comfort for all types of sleepers. .

The cover is a stylish polyester blend with a white top and heather grey sides. The material is soft to the touch and quite breathable which helps the sleeping surface to remain cool.

Considerations

  • The Casper offers a 100-night trial period for you to decide whether not this mattress is right for you. If you decide that you do not want to keep The Casper, they will pick up the bed for free.
  • 10-year limited warranty.
  • Free Shipping in the Continental United States and Canada.
  • CertiPUR-US® Certified – Casper mattresses were tested and met the exhaustive conditions for environmental standards.
  • Made in the USA.

Saatva and Casper Comparison

So you are probably wondering how these two mattress models stack up next to each other? We’ll break it down into similarities and differences

How are Casper and Saatva Similar

Price

These two brands are very similarly priced. This difference is only $4 when looking at queens. This makes money a non-factor in purchasing decision. The Casper is available in Queen-size for $995, while Saatva is available in Queen-size for $999

Firmness

These two beds are very close when it comes to how firm they feel. Most Saatva reviews give a firmness of around 7 to 7.5 out of 10. This rating puts this particular mattress a little towards the medium-firm side of medium. Many Casper reviews rate this bed’s firmness at  7 out of 10. This puts this bed’s firmness in-between medium and medium-firm.

Back & Stomach Comfort

Both of these mattresses are wonderful for back and stomach sleepers. Saatva and The Casper mattresses do a fantastic job of distributing weight down the entire length of your body without arching your back while sleeping on your stomach or

Free Delivery

Both save you trouble by delivering to your doorstep. Saatva even goes a step further and offers installation.

How are Casper and Saatva Different?

The Warranty

While Caspers 10-year limited warranty is nothing to scoff at, Saatva goes 50% further and provides you with 15-years of protection for your investment.

Sleep Trial Returns

Although Saatva offers an extra 20 days on their trial, they charge you $99 to return their mattress. Casper will pick up the returned product free of charge and refund 100% of your money.

Construction

Saatva innerspring hybrid mattress. Directly under the quilting is a layer of convoluted foam. This term means that it is shaped with peaks and valleys or waves to coincide with the pillow top. As I just mentioned, there is an extra strip of foam across the lumbar area of the bed to create a bit more support for that region.

884 individually wrapped coils (in a queen-sized) make up the next layer. These coils add bounce, helping you to sleep on top of the mattress, rather than in the mattress where you might get that stuck feeling commonly associated with traditional memory foam beds. The individually wrapped coils also help to transfer motion better than conventional box springs.

The base layer is made up of steel support coils encased in high-density polyurethane foam. The polyfoam bordering acts as a transition between the two sets of coils and also adds fantastic edge-support.

The Casper is all-foam and consists of four layers. On the top, the comfort layer is a proprietary open-cell latex-like foam that gives the bed a little bit of bounce. It is ultra-responsive to pressure. It’s also infused with cooling properties that help keep the surface cool while you sleep.

The contour layer consists of high-quality memory foam. This section is what gives the bed its classic conforming feeling. The third layer is Casper’s trademarked Zone Support. This section is the transition layer we spoke of that recently got revamped. It is constructed using two different types of polyfoam and is meant to customize the amount of support for each region of the human body.

The base of the bed is made up of a high-density foundation layer. This thick, durable foam is what gives The Casper its shape and strength.

How They Feel

Casper: The latex foam in the comfort layer is highly responsive. It adds a little more bounce to the Casper than traditional memory foam beds. Because of this, you sleep on top of the bed with just enough sinkage to cradle your body but not feel stuck. This combination provides a pleasing balance between traditional feel and memory foam feel. Sleepers who are used to either should be able to adjust to the feel of this bed quickly.

The Casper’s updated transition layer provides head-to-toe support and relieves the correct amount of pressure across the different zones of your body. They achieve this by using a slightly softer foam near your head and shoulders and below the knees. And a slightly stronger foam to support the core area of your body. They did a great job of creating a system that relieves pressure and helps to keep your spine aligned in any sleeping position.

The removable polyester-blend cover is relatively thin. The material is soft and breathable. The cover works well with the open-cell comfort layer to transfer trapped heat away from the body and keep the mattress cool underneath of you.

Saatva: In short, it feels like a 5-Star hotel bed. You immediately notice that it has a very bouncy feel. The pillow top and convoluted foam conform to your body, so there is a little more sink than you would find in a standard innerspring mattress. But you still lay on top of the bed, not stuck in the bed, so movement remains natural.

The Saatva does a great job of distributing weight evenly across the mattress. Stomach sleepers and back sleepers should be more than happy with the Saatva’s Luxury Firm mattress.

You can feel a small amount of pressure on the hips and shoulders while laying on your side, and these points show up on pressure maps as well. This won’t be a problem for petite or average-sized people, but heavier side-sleepers may not experience the same amount of comfort.

Overall, this mattress has that classic innerspring feel, but that of a much pricier one. It is looks and feels very well built. The materials are high quality, and Saatva doesn’t cut corners with the stitching.

Edge Support

Saatva is the clear-cut winner in this department. Their product has unbeatable edge support in their price class. They absolutely destroy all of the competition in this area. The layer of high-density foam that encases the innersprings provides unparalleled side/edge support. This aspect makes the Saatva ideal for couples.

Motion Transfer

Saatva, with all of its individual coils, is much better than most innerspring beds. However, it still doesn’t compare to its latex foam and memory foam competition in its ability to absorb energy transfer. Hard jolts tend to interact with the inner coils, thus transferring that energy across the bed. If you flop into bed, your partner will feel it. Casper, on the other hand, does a much better job of absorbing energy and stopping motion transfer.

Pressure Relief

Pressure maps show Casper to be the clear winner in relieving pressure on prominent areas such as hips, shoulders, and the buttocks. This makes the Casper more suitable for heavier people and side sleepers.

And the Winning Mattress is …

The Casper Mattress Buy Online Now

We’re confident recommending The Casper as the best choice based on our analysis of key factors that an average, discerning mattress shopper would care most about. This was a hard-fought battle, and in many ways, the Saatva is a ‘higher quality’ mattress because it is built so darn well. But this showdown is about which bed will be more comfortable to the masses.

Casper Sleep’s upgrades to its Zone Support™ in the transitional layer make this bed a fantastic choice whether you sleep on your stomach, side, back, or all of the above. Saatva is a beautiful mattress, but it comes up just a little short for side sleepers.

**Table Content**

  • Quality – Saatva
  • Body Support – Casper
  • Price – Tie
  • Reputation – Tie
  • Sleep Trial – Casper (they don’t charge you for returns)
  • Warranty – Saatva
  • Customer Support – Saatva by a hair
  • Product Selection – Casper

For Sleepers with Specific Needs

Side Sleepers: Choose the Casper

Side sleepers will find Casper’s bed in a box a delight. It relieves pressure along the hips and shoulders, creating a pleasant sleeping experience.

Stomach Sleepers: Choose the Casper

Stomach sleepers are supported evenly down the length of their body. This keeps the back from arching and pressure off of the chest area. The cooling properties of The Casper mattress are also ideal for stomach sleepers.

People with Back Pain: Choose the Casper

The Casper’s trademarked Support Zone promotes proper spinal alignment and bodily support in any sleeping position. This allows for spinal decompression over time and can reduce chronic back pain.

Heavy People: Choose the Casper

Larger people prefer the Casper because their weight is evenly distributed and there are no springs to push into prominent pressure areas. They are also much less likely to ‘bottom out’.

Couples: Choose the Casper

Although Saatva has far superior edge support, couples prefer the Casper because of its limited motion transfer. An individual getting in and out of bed will not disturb the other party nearly as much.

Conclusion

It comes down to the fact that The Casper will provide comfort regardless of sleep position or body type. Saatva’s Luxury Firm mattress is a high-quality product and will work for many people, but side sleepers and heavier individuals might find it lacking.

For this reason, we are confident in our choice that The Casper is better all-around sleep product.

Tim

Remember how your parents told you that you were going to sleep your life away? Well that would be perfectly fine with Tim. He's been in search of the most comfortable nights sleep for years and shares his findings with any willing ear.

View all posts

Add comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Sleep Like a Baby

Get tips, tricks and product recommendations to help you sleep through the night.

You're in! As a thank you enjoy $25 Off Our Favorite Pillow.

Pin It on Pinterest